Results 1 to 17 of 17
08-21-07, 01:59 PM #1
Illegal Presence in US Not A Crime, Court Says
Illegal Presence in US Not A Crime, Court Says
By Jeff Golimowski
CNSNews.com Senior Staff Writer
August 21, 2007
(1st Add: Includes comments from Barton County Attorney Douglas Matthews.)
(CNSNews.com) - If you can get past the border guards and into the United States, you're no longer violating the law, according to a Kansas Court of Appeals decision.
The ruling comes after an illegal immigrant, Nicholas Martinez, was sentenced to a year in jail after pleading guilty to possession of cocaine and endangering a child. Court documents say Martinez was caught in an undercover sting by detectives in Barton County, Kansas (about 120 miles northwest of Wichita), using his young son to help sell cocaine.
Under Kansas law, the charges (and plea bargain) would have landed Martinez on probation. But the judge in the case said the defendant couldn't be put on probation because of his immigration status.
"Mr. Martinez is illegally in the country and is in violation of the probation rules right from the start if I place him on probation," court documents quoted Judge Hannelore Kitts as saying. "He has to comply with all the conditions of the probation and he can't do that because he's in violation of the law not to violate any federal or state laws."
The judge then rejected the plea agreement's sentencing recommendation and ordered Martinez to spend a year in jail.
"I don't want to speak for her, but the judge obviously believed there was an inconsistency in placing him on probation when one of the first things he would have been told was to obey the law," said Barton County Attorney Douglas Matthews.
But on appeal, a three-judge panel threw out the sentence, based on an apparent contradiction in U.S. law. While it is illegal to enter the country without the proper documents and permissions, it is not necessarily illegal to be in the country.
In its opinion, the court explained that Congress had implicitly created the distinction: "While Congress has criminalized the illegal entry into this country, it has not made the continued presence of an illegal alien in the United States a crime unless the illegal alien has previously been deported," said the opinion.
The court also cited previous cases, including a 1958 Supreme Court case, which found that laws regarding illegal entry into the country "are not continuing ones, as 'entry' is limited to a particular locality and hardly suggests continuity."
Because the judge hadn't determined whether Martinez had been deported previously, the appeals court ruled she had no legal basis to deny probation, since simply being in the country isn't necessarily a crime.
A pre-sentence investigation by the court did not find any evidence Martinez had been previously deported.
Matthews said this is one of if not the first time this issue has been brought before a Kansas court, though similar cases have been heard in Oregon and Minnesota with similar results. He said he doesn't necessarily believe the ruling will have far-reaching effects, as the language of the opinion was extremely narrow.
"The Court narrowed the conditions under which (Martinez) could be imprisoned for his violation of Kansas law," said Matthews. "The mere fact that you're in Kansas illegally does not mean, at least according to this opinion, that one of our District Court judges can impose a prison sentence as opposed to probation after you've been convicted of a felony offense."
Prosecutors have 30 days to appeal the ruling to the Kansas Supreme Court.
If you enter illegally, then you're here illegally plain and simple in my book. Just my 2 cents worth.
08-21-07, 03:35 PM #2
WTF? Someone help me with this please. How is a person on American soil illegally able to have the same rights as I do?Do not war for peace. If you must war, war for justice. For without justice there is no peace. -me
We are who we choose to be.
R.I.P. Arielle. 08/20/2010-09/16/2012
08-21-07, 03:35 PM #3
Reminds me of that shirt " What part of ILLEGAL don't you understand?"
08-21-07, 03:44 PM #4
All I can say is WOW!!!"An Unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it." Jeff Cooper
Some people are meant to be the police......Some people are meant to call the police!!!
"Socialism only works in two places: Heaven where they don't need it and hell where they already have it."
" I believe that forgiving them (Terrorist) is God's function. OUR job is to arrange the meeting."
General Norman Schwartzkopf
Not all Muslims are Terrorists, but all Terrorists are Muslim.
The statements posted by BigDawg DO NOT reflect the opinions, views, policies, or procedures of the author's employing agency. These statements are the personal opinions of BigDawg only, thereby releasing my agency of any liability, or involvement in anything posted under the user name of BigDawg. The opinions expressed by BigDawg are protected by the 1st Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. BigDawg’s messages are intended to invoke thought and discussion among the "Officer Resources" forum community and may not necessarily reflect the opinion of the author. BigDawg’s posts and any attachments are intended for an adult audience (18+) and may contain strong language, sexual content, nudity, violence, and may be graphic in nature. Some material may be considered offensive; reader discretion is advised. Please note that many of BigDawg’s posts are intended for entertainment value only. BigDawg’s posts are not intended to be used where prohibited by law. Furthermore, BigDawg's posts, and any attachments, may contain information covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510-2521, and is confidential and proprietary in nature. If you are not the intended recipient, please be advised that you are legally prohibited from retaining, using, copying, distributing, or otherwise disclosing this information in any manner.
08-21-07, 03:45 PM #5
Looks like I can move to Kansas then, who needs them green card thingies anyway!the sole advantage of power is that you can do more good.
( Baltasar Gracian )
08-21-07, 03:55 PM #6
This made me wonder, why the hell do we have the immigration process anyway? Come on over people!
08-21-07, 03:57 PM #7Banned
- Join Date
- Aguascalients, Mexico
- Rep Power
I don't get this at all!! Why wasn't he deported? Why wasn't he deported the minute it was discovered he was illegal thus saving the US the court and jail costs? How can it be illegal to cross the border without documents but not illegal to live in the US without documents? And if that's the law, then all the "illegals" aren't illegal, are they? What a mess!!
08-21-07, 06:10 PM #8
So by that logic,,,,,, if you rob a bank and make it home, and manage to spend the money before it's found on you then your free. Nothing illegal. So what do we call them now? The people formerly known as illegals?? I'll bet Prince would not like anybody else going by the "formerly known as" moniker.
Oly Oly Oxen Free.... I touched base and I'm home safe! You can't get me!
08-21-07, 07:20 PM #9
The United States of America - AKA - "The Sanctuary"No one has greater love than this, to lay down ones life for ones friends - John 15:13
"The Wicked Flee When No Man Pursueth: But The Righteous Are Bold As A Lion".
We lucky few, we band of brothers. For he who today sheds his blood with me shall be my brother.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~The opinions, beliefs, and ideas expressed in this post are mine, and mine alone. They are NOT the opinions, beliefs, ideas, or policies of my Agency, Police Chief, City Council, or any member of my department.
08-21-07, 10:00 PM #10
I'm thinking Federal Courts are going to have a field day with this. By the time they are finished, these judges will be wiping their ass with their robes.
"The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money."
- Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America
Tell me not, Sweet, I am unkind,
That from the nunnery
Of thy chaste breast and quiet mind
To war and arms I fly. - Lovelace
The opinions expressed by this poster are wholly his own, and should never be construed to even remotely be in representation of his employer, its agencies or assigns. In fact, they probably fail to be in alignment with the opinions of any rational human being.
08-21-07, 10:38 PM #11\\` ` ` ` < ` )___/\
`` ` ` ` (3--(____)
"...but to forget your duck, of course, means you're really screwed." - Gary Larson
08-21-07, 10:45 PM #12The true measure of your character is what you choose to do when you think no one is looking.
08-22-07, 12:20 AM #13
This represented Congress's reversal of that portion of the Dred Scott v. Sandford decision that declared that African Americans were not and could not become citizens of the United States or enjoy any of the privileges and immunities of citizenship. The Civil Rights Act of 1866 had already granted U.S. citizenship to all people born in the United States; the framers of the Fourteenth Amendment enshrined this principle in the Constitution in order to stop the Supreme Court from ruling it unconstitutional for want of congressional authority to pass such a law, or from a future Congress altering it by a bare majority vote.
However, the phrase and subject to the jurisdiction thereof indicates that there are some exceptions to the universal rule that birth on U.S. soil automatically grants citizenship. The following persons born in the United States are not considered "subject to the jurisdiction [of the United States]", and thus do not qualify for automatic citizenship under the Fourteenth Amendment:
Children born to foreign diplomats;
Children born to enemy forces in hostile occupation of the United States;
Children born to Native Americans who are members of tribes not taxed (these were later given full citizenship by the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924).
The following persons born in the United States are explicitly citizens:
Children born to US citizens;
Children born to aliens who are lawfully inside the United States (resident or visitor), with the intention of amicably interacting with its people and obeying its laws.
The Supreme Court's ruling in Plyler v. Doe stated that illegal immigrants are "within the jurisdiction" of the states in which they reside, and added in a footnote that "no plausible distinction with respect to Fourteenth Amendment 'jurisdiction' can be drawn between resident aliens whose entry into the United States was lawful, and resident aliens whose entry was unlawful." Some legislators, reacting to illegal immigration, have proposed that this be changed, either through legislation or a constitutional amendment.Don't Be Afraid To Fail.
No Tengas Miedo Al Fracaso.
08-22-07, 12:25 AM #14
ATTENTION ILLEGALS: MOVE TO KANSAS!!!!
08-22-07, 12:26 AM #15
They do not, by their lack of proximity from a border of the United States, magically become legal on their own or by this or any other courts decision.Don't Be Afraid To Fail.
No Tengas Miedo Al Fracaso.
08-22-07, 01:10 AM #16
unbelievable... just hang my head and shake it =/-=Twan007
Lack of planning on your part does not constitute an emergency on mine.
Not one shred of evidence supports the notion that life is serious.
The opinions expressed by this poster are wholly his own, and should never be construed to even remotely be in alignment with his employer. Matter of fact, the poster will deny any knowledge of any post... this message will self-destruct in 5 seconds...
08-22-07, 02:37 AM #17
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)