• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Subscribe to the Magazine
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Featured
    • Operation Gratitude stops by NYPD precinct
      Drury University “Badge to Bachelors” program offers scholarships...
      HBCU makes history
      “We were swamped”— gun permits surge in Wake County
      Stray beagle finds a home and purpose with local police
  • Topics
    • On the Job
      • Good Samaritans rescue police officer from burning vehicle
        NYPD will deploy undercover officers in Asian communities for...
        Portland police chief takes responsibility for leaks damaging...
        Half of troopers at a Michigan State Police outpost are women
        Lessons learned: How police strategy has evolved to deal with mass...
    • Labor
      • NYPD unions attribute rise in crime to bail reform laws
        Seattle police budget cuts lead to slower response times for priority...
        The Firefighter Corollary
        New Jersey “Burnout Bill” could allow police officers and...
        Union says “many” U.S. Capitol Police officers want to leave the...
    • Tech
      • Law enforcement begins testing Skydio drones
        Technology gives police an edge in chases
        Data-driven investigations
        Police technology: Why so far behind?
        Charlotte-Mecklenburg police use key technology to battle crime wave
    • Training
      • Patterns, habits and deviations
        Training the best for the worst
        “We were swamped”— gun permits surge in Wake County
        Firearms vs. scenario-based training
        New PT standard for future officers draws objections
    • Policy
      • San Francisco lawmaker wants California to repeal its jaywalking due...
        Texas House bill takes aim law enforcement on reality TV
        Arizona bill would limit civilians on police review boards
        Iowa bill banning combined police and fire departments targets Cedar...
        California bill to mandate handgun microstamping would increase costs...
    • Health/Wellness
      • Awareness is not enough
        Practicing gratitude
        Post-traumatic stress: causes, symptoms and ways to heal
        Busted: Five myths about marital counseling
        Pandemic, protests and purpose
    • Community
      • Former police officer continues to serve the community by teaching at...
        Fueling goodwill
        Nonprofit foundation strengthens relationships between students and...
        Operation Gratitude stops by NYPD precinct
        Flag flareup
    • Humor
      • Alabama police capture runaway kangaroo
        The missing kangaroo returns home to Stokoe Farms in Scottsville
        Chick-Fil-A customer door-checks fleeing suspect
        Wisconsin driver pulled over for driving while seated on a camping...
        North Carolina sheriff’s office offers humorous “Valentine’s...
    • We Remember
      • Boulder residents pay respects to fallen officer Eric Talley
        Locked up forever
        Tampa Bay grieves over the loss of officers
        New Jersey police veteran who helped in 9/11 aftermath dies
        LA Police Officer Reinstated 120 Years after Being Unjustly Fired
  • On the Job
    • Good Samaritans rescue police officer from burning vehicle
      NYPD will deploy undercover officers in Asian communities for...
      Portland police chief takes responsibility for leaks damaging...
      Half of troopers at a Michigan State Police outpost are women
      Lessons learned: How police strategy has evolved to deal with mass...
  • Labor
    • NYPD unions attribute rise in crime to bail reform laws
      Seattle police budget cuts lead to slower response times for priority...
      The Firefighter Corollary
      New Jersey “Burnout Bill” could allow police officers and...
      Union says “many” U.S. Capitol Police officers want to leave the...
  • Tech
    • Law enforcement begins testing Skydio drones
      Technology gives police an edge in chases
      Data-driven investigations
      Police technology: Why so far behind?
      Charlotte-Mecklenburg police use key technology to battle crime wave
  • Training
    • Patterns, habits and deviations
      Training the best for the worst
      “We were swamped”— gun permits surge in Wake County
      Firearms vs. scenario-based training
      New PT standard for future officers draws objections
  • Policy
    • San Francisco lawmaker wants California to repeal its jaywalking due...
      Texas House bill takes aim law enforcement on reality TV
      Arizona bill would limit civilians on police review boards
      Iowa bill banning combined police and fire departments targets Cedar...
      California bill to mandate handgun microstamping would increase costs...
  • Health/Wellness
    • Awareness is not enough
      Practicing gratitude
      Post-traumatic stress: causes, symptoms and ways to heal
      Busted: Five myths about marital counseling
      Pandemic, protests and purpose
  • Community
    • Former police officer continues to serve the community by teaching at...
      Fueling goodwill
      Nonprofit foundation strengthens relationships between students and...
      Operation Gratitude stops by NYPD precinct
      Flag flareup
  • Humor
    • Alabama police capture runaway kangaroo
      The missing kangaroo returns home to Stokoe Farms in Scottsville
      Chick-Fil-A customer door-checks fleeing suspect
      Wisconsin driver pulled over for driving while seated on a camping...
      North Carolina sheriff’s office offers humorous “Valentine’s...
  • We Remember
    • Boulder residents pay respects to fallen officer Eric Talley
      Locked up forever
      Tampa Bay grieves over the loss of officers
      New Jersey police veteran who helped in 9/11 aftermath dies
      LA Police Officer Reinstated 120 Years after Being Unjustly Fired
  • Jobs and Careers
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Search

Health/Wellness

Awareness is not enough

Training to overcome brain bias (with neuroscience)

Joy VerPlanck, D.E.T., and Lois James, Ph.D. Published March 31, 2021 @ 6:00 am PDT

iStock.com/imaginima

Implicit bias training is not a new nor a progressive agenda in policing — rather, it has been a topic among industry leaders and a key component of 21st-century policing established prior to the current pressure of a society calling for reform. Regardless of the industry-wide acceptance of need, not all agencies have been quick — or able — to embrace it. Unfortunately, increased scrutiny on imbalances in police training has caused straggler agencies to finally accept the need, only to find themselves in a scramble to meet minimum standards with minimal funding and dwindling staff. 

Minimum training gets minimum results

According to IADLEST spokesman Dr. James Copple, implicit bias training is more important for the development of effective policing in a community-supported environment than tactical training. It provides critical skills for what comprises the vast majority of daily interactions. Any component in a law enforcement training program carrying this magnitude of significance deserves full attention, careful assessment and serious implementation.

Bias is a necessary-by-design component of the body’s physiological response to threat. “If you have a brain, you have bias,” explained Dr. Kamila Sip, senior director of science at the NeuroLeadership Institute, during a recent webinar series on the Neuroscience of De-Escalation. This simple statement is presented as a harsh reality, approached with care so as not to offend anyone in the audience who might incorrectly confuse bias with racism. Unlike racism, though, structures of cognitive bias that exist within all humans are actually supposed to be there. Well-defined, irrefutable, helpful, adaptive and applicable in every aspect of our lives, biases exist within our species — in part — to keep us alive and thriving.

Sometimes, though, biases can work against us. They can go rogue, becoming quite unhelpful and negatively impacting our perceptions and actions. With the existence of unruly subconscious elements coded into the design of our humanity, how can we possibly train to overcome them?

Well-defined, irrefutable, helpful, adaptive and applicable in every aspect of our lives, biases exist within our species — in part — to keep us alive and thriving.

The answer — like bias— is in the brain

Neuroscience tells us there are 150 cognitive biases based on underlying biological components[1]Lieberman, M., Rock, D., Halvorson, H., and Cox, C. (2016). Breaking Bias Updated: The SEEDS Model®. NeuroLeadership Journal, v6. that can be placed into categories for easy understanding and application. Once a person learns how to recognize and compartmentalize those biological signals, trainees can learn to mitigate implicit bias and ensure inappropriate and dangerous bias-driven behavior is minimized. To achieve advanced cognitive processing, follow these three steps in training implementation:

  1. Accept. Understanding that we all have implicit bias — that we are not to blame but are nonetheless responsible for the impact our implicit biases may have — is the critical first step in safeguarding against biased decision making. One of the key steps toward acceptance is in the understanding of why this training is needed. Research shows that to have the motivation to learn new knowledge, adult learners must value the instruction and find it applicable in their own view of the world.[2]Wlodkowski, R.J. and Ginsberg, M.B., 2017. Enhancing adult motivation to learn: A comprehensive guide for teaching all adults. John Wiley & Sons. Leaders, take note! Convey the need for implicit bias training responsibly and with positive intent.
  2. Label. The process of labeling bias takes training a step further, and like other modalities, this process must be scientifically approached if it is going to stick. Calling out the behavior — especially when in a rapid response situation — requires 1) an easy model to help the trainee quickly categorize the bias that they recognize,[3]Lieberman, M., Rock, D., Halvorson, H., and Cox, C. (2016). Breaking Bias Updated: The SEEDS Model®. NeuroLeadership Journal, v6. and 2) psychological safety with teams engaging together in the training space.[4]Edmondson, A.C., 2018. The fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. John Wiley & Sons. Labeling biases can feel like an admission of guilt, even though the early development of that bias may not be our fault. There can be no judgment among teams seeking to improve, and that takes a supportive culture within the agency that is receptive to what can, at times, be an uncomfortable path to growth.
  3. Mitigate. Strategies that teach officers how to check their biases in the moment and continually self-monitor are critical in order to become a behavior-modifying process. This requires a learning function called generation — the act of creating a personal connection to the information.[5]Davis, J., Balda, M., Rock, D., McGinniss, P., and Davachi, L., 2014. The Science of Making Learning Stick: An Update to the AGES Model, NeuroLeadership Journal, v5. One promising approach is using force option simulation to allow trainees to interact with a diverse group of people in a wide range of police–citizen encounters. Actively practicing the skills of recognizing and countering biases is critical for safeguarding against biased policing on the street.[6]James, L., Fridell, L. and Straub, F., 2016. Implicit bias versus the “Ferguson Effect”: Psychosocial factors impacting officers’ decisions to use deadly force. The Police Chief, 83, pp.44-51.

Officers who understand brain bias are better equipped to recognize it — but awareness only becomes behavior change when they train their brains to overcome it.

The majority of implicit bias training stops at awareness when the material is delivered in a direct instruction (sit-and-get) method. Being aware of and accepting the existence of bias is necessary, but awareness is not enough to ensure that bias no longer subconsciously influences behavior. A recent, comprehensive, empirical evaluation of direct instruction methods used by NYPD revealed the uncomfortable reality that awareness-only methods may be fine for implementation but fall short when it comes to results. Reported reasons for the failure in behavioral change include not understanding or recalling how to implement and not believing their efforts would be
effective.

For knowledge to stick, the learning environment must be conducive to growth, and the curriculum must be built upon an academically sound framework of educational/behavioral theory and cognitive neuroscience. The training must be facilitated by an experienced educator and be engaging enough to trigger the emotional response required for deep cognitive processing. As agencies approach reform efforts and make attempts to provide a well-trained team of professionals who are trusted within their communities, counter-bias training that meets all of these criteria must be incorporated.


Dr. Joy VerPlanck is the senior researcher for applied science at MILO Training Solutions, with a Doctorate of Educational Technology from Central Michigan University. Dr. Lois James is the assistant director for research at the Washington State University College of Nursing, and the founding director of CBTsim. 

As seen in the March 2021 issue of American Police Beat magazine.
Don’t miss out on another issue today! Click below:

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

References[+]

References
1, 3 Lieberman, M., Rock, D., Halvorson, H., and Cox, C. (2016). Breaking Bias Updated: The SEEDS Model®. NeuroLeadership Journal, v6.
2 Wlodkowski, R.J. and Ginsberg, M.B., 2017. Enhancing adult motivation to learn: A comprehensive guide for teaching all adults. John Wiley & Sons.
4 Edmondson, A.C., 2018. The fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. John Wiley & Sons.
5 Davis, J., Balda, M., Rock, D., McGinniss, P., and Davachi, L., 2014. The Science of Making Learning Stick: An Update to the AGES Model, NeuroLeadership Journal, v5.
6 James, L., Fridell, L. and Straub, F., 2016. Implicit bias versus the “Ferguson Effect”: Psychosocial factors impacting officers’ decisions to use deadly force. The Police Chief, 83, pp.44-51.

Categories: Health/Wellness

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • Good Samaritans rescue police officer from burning vehicle
  • NYPD will deploy undercover officers in Asian communities for protection
  • Portland police chief takes responsibility for leaks damaging public’s trust
  • Boulder residents pay respects to fallen officer Eric Talley
  • Half of troopers at a Michigan State Police outpost are women
  • San Francisco lawmaker wants California to repeal its jaywalking due to disproportionate enforcement against people of color
  • Former police officer continues to serve the community by teaching at local schools
  • Texas House bill takes aim law enforcement on reality TV
  • Lessons learned: How police strategy has evolved to deal with mass shootings
  • Arizona bill would limit civilians on police review boards
Advertise with APB

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Categories

  • Featured
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Humor
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers

Editor’s Picks

Ass-kissing, favoritism, oh my!

Ass-kissing, favoritism, oh my!

January 28, 2021

This K-9 is a gym rat at heart!

This K-9 is a gym rat at heart!

January 25, 2021

A thread of courage and love

A thread of courage and love

January 20, 2021

The job doesn’t love you back

The job doesn’t love you back

December 28, 2020

Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2021 American Police Beat, Inc. | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close
Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.