• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Subscribe to the Magazine
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Editor’s Picks
    • Seeking the right kind of help
      “Why does that call keep haunting me?”
      Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em
      A message to those considering suicide
      The power of teamwork
  • Topics
    • On the Job
      • California deputies rescue teen dangling 700 feet in the air after...
        Washington deputy rescues injured dog from drainpipe
        “Wow, our career together is over”: Missouri police department...
        Heroic Pennsylvania officer saves father and daughter from drowning...
        Denver law enforcement struggle to divert low-level offenders to...
    • Labor
      • San Francisco “workhorse” deputy earns millions in overtime pay...
        “A financial tsunami”
        LAPD officers receive raises, bonuses
        Minnesota police force faces disbandment as chief resigns amid salary...
        We quit!
    • Tech
      • The rise of I2P
        Ann Arbor Police Department adopts AI technology to analyze body...
        Ohio law enforcement adopts powerful ballistics technology to combat...
        AI-powered surveillance program raises concerns over privacy rights...
        Chesterfield County announces real-time crime center to enhance...
    • Training
      • Investigating “swatting” incidents
        Leaders take note: A handwritten note goes a long way
        CIT training is not for everyone
        Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em
        Ohio struggles to secure permanent funding for law enforcement...
    • Policy
      • Texas enacts stricter laws to combat illegal street racing and...
        New Mexico Supreme Court clarifies police authority to question...
        New Texas law gives local law enforcement greater control over...
        Diversity in law enforcement
        Florida attorney general and John Walsh partner in new Crime Stoppers...
    • Health/Wellness
      • The emotional rucksack
        What threat does to the brain
        Seeking the right kind of help
        Working through grief
        Responding to trauma
    • Community
      • Florida police department launches SPORTS initiative to build...
        Naperville police officer inspires generations of kids through reading
        Stockton P.D. launches Your Way Registry Program to protect...
        Committing to outreach
        Scam callers pose as law enforcement to trick victims into paying for...
    • Offbeat
      • “It’s time to dive in”: Shaquille O’Neal joins forces with...
        “This little piggy didn’t make it to the market”:
        Seattle police find burglary suspect guzzling gasoline in victim’s...
        Univision Chicago TV crew reporting on armed robberies held at...
        California Highway Patrol arrests man on horseback for DUI
    • We Remember
      • Headstone finally marks grave of Pennsylvania officer who gave his...
        Memorial for the fallen: The sacrifice continues
        Paying Tribute to the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
        “He was like a protector …”: Genesee County sheriff’s deputy...
        Deadly police pursuit claims life of 19-year-old Vermont police...
  • On the Job
    • California deputies rescue teen dangling 700 feet in the air after...
      Washington deputy rescues injured dog from drainpipe
      “Wow, our career together is over”: Missouri police department...
      Heroic Pennsylvania officer saves father and daughter from drowning...
      Denver law enforcement struggle to divert low-level offenders to...
  • Labor
    • San Francisco “workhorse” deputy earns millions in overtime pay...
      “A financial tsunami”
      LAPD officers receive raises, bonuses
      Minnesota police force faces disbandment as chief resigns amid salary...
      We quit!
  • Tech
    • The rise of I2P
      Ann Arbor Police Department adopts AI technology to analyze body...
      Ohio law enforcement adopts powerful ballistics technology to combat...
      AI-powered surveillance program raises concerns over privacy rights...
      Chesterfield County announces real-time crime center to enhance...
  • Training
    • Investigating “swatting” incidents
      Leaders take note: A handwritten note goes a long way
      CIT training is not for everyone
      Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em
      Ohio struggles to secure permanent funding for law enforcement...
  • Policy
    • Texas enacts stricter laws to combat illegal street racing and...
      New Mexico Supreme Court clarifies police authority to question...
      New Texas law gives local law enforcement greater control over...
      Diversity in law enforcement
      Florida attorney general and John Walsh partner in new Crime Stoppers...
  • Health/Wellness
    • The emotional rucksack
      What threat does to the brain
      Seeking the right kind of help
      Working through grief
      Responding to trauma
  • Community
    • Florida police department launches SPORTS initiative to build...
      Naperville police officer inspires generations of kids through reading
      Stockton P.D. launches Your Way Registry Program to protect...
      Committing to outreach
      Scam callers pose as law enforcement to trick victims into paying for...
  • Offbeat
    • “It’s time to dive in”: Shaquille O’Neal joins forces with...
      “This little piggy didn’t make it to the market”:
      Seattle police find burglary suspect guzzling gasoline in victim’s...
      Univision Chicago TV crew reporting on armed robberies held at...
      California Highway Patrol arrests man on horseback for DUI
  • We Remember
    • Headstone finally marks grave of Pennsylvania officer who gave his...
      Memorial for the fallen: The sacrifice continues
      Paying Tribute to the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
      “He was like a protector …”: Genesee County sheriff’s deputy...
      Deadly police pursuit claims life of 19-year-old Vermont police...
  • Between the Lines
    • Debunking the perpetual narrative of racial bias in policing
      The unspoken truth behind the recruitment and retention crisis
      The police reform goal: use of force without options
      The imprisonment of law enforcement technology
      Persecution of the LEO is classic schadenfreude
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Search

Policy

San Francisco votes to expand autonomous vehicle services despite pushback from first responders

APB Team Published August 19, 2023 @ 3:00 pm PDT

iStock.com/Just_Super

In a pivotal vote held on August 10, the California Public Utilities Commission granted Alphabet Inc.’s Waymo and General Motors’ Cruise the permission to operate autonomous vehicles as paid taxis throughout San Francisco at all hours, solidifying the city’s position as a hub for the autonomous vehicle (AV) industry.

The decision came after a heated debate, pitting proponents of technological advancement against concerns raised by first responders and city agencies.

The vote, which was preceded by more than six hours of public comment, marks a significant stride in the development of self-driving technology, as it allows Waymo and Cruise to expand their robotaxi services and is expected to lead to a considerable increase in the number of autonomous vehicles on the city’s roads.

Despite the decision, there were notable concerns voiced by San Francisco’s police and fire departments, who have witnessed numerous incidents of AVs interfering with emergency operations.

San Francisco Fire Chief Jeanine Nicholson spoke about her concerns and called for prioritizing safety.

“I’m not trying to stop technology from moving forward, nor would I ever have the power to do so. What I am is pro-safety,” she said in a statement.

The fire department also reported 55 “unusual occurrence” incidents involving autonomous vehicles interfering with their operations, with most occurring since April of the current year.

In several instances, autonomous vehicles interfered with response zones or unexpectedly blocked access to fire stations, causing firefighters in one incident to spend a half an hour reorienting the vehicle.

“That’s just unacceptable,” Nicholson said. “I will reiterate; it is not our job to babysit their vehicles.”

In addition, firefighters also raised concerns about the lack of transparency in data provided by self-driving car companies, citing incomplete or duplicate reports due to the absence of direct information sharing.

Representatives from Waymo and Cruise acknowledged the concerns and proposed training programs for first responders to interact with autonomous vehicles effectively. However, the proposals did not resonate well with the responders, who called the need for AV companies to develop technology that better recognizes emergency scenarios.

“They need to be trained on how to interact with us and not have multi-layers of bureaucracy between us,” Fire Deputy Chief of Operations Darius Luttropp said.

Critics argue that while autonomous vehicles offer potential benefits, the technology is not yet ready for unrestricted deployment.

San Francisco Firefighters Union Secretary Adam Wood also urged a cautious approach, asserting that the incidents would likely continue and even increase with the removal of restrictions.

Law enforcement agencies also raised concerns about the vote.

SFPD Commander Nicole Jones said the explosion of 41 authorized autonomous companies in California could complicate agency’s response to emergencies.

“We want to be able to deal with emergency situations quickly and effectively,” she said. “If there are 41 different protocols that have to be followed, 41 different phone numbers that have to be called, it’s just a lot.”

City Commissioner John Reynolds, who also worked as managing counsel for Cruise, addressed some of the concerns, stating that he believed in the potential of AVs to enhance road safety, but declared the importance of complying with commands issued to the vehicles.

The decision to expand AV services marks a significant milestone in the industry’s evolution. Waymo and Cruise now can deploy more vehicles for round-the-clock operations, directly competing with established ride-hailing companies such as Uber and Lyft, as well as city taxi companies.

As the number of autonomous vehicles on San Francisco’s roads increases, stakeholders will be keenly watching for improvements in technology and safety.

Categories: Policy Tags: San Francisco, firefighters, emergency response, vote, autonomous vehicles, Waymo, self-driving cars, robotaxi, first responders, California

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • California deputies rescue teen dangling 700 feet in the air after botched stunt on state’s highest bridge
  • Washington deputy rescues injured dog from drainpipe
  • “It’s time to dive in”: Shaquille O’Neal joins forces with Los Angeles Port Police Department in recruitment drive
  • “This little piggy didn’t make it to the market”:
  • Florida police department launches SPORTS initiative to build positive community relationships
  • Seattle police find burglary suspect guzzling gasoline in victim’s garage
  • The emotional rucksack
  • Naperville police officer inspires generations of kids through reading
  • “Wow, our career together is over”: Missouri police department bids farewell to retiring K-9 Tank
  • Investigating “swatting” incidents

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

Seeking the right kind of help

Seeking the right kind of help

September 26, 2023

“Why does that call keep haunting me?”

“Why does that call keep haunting me?”

September 20, 2023

Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em

Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em

September 19, 2023

A message to those considering suicide

A message to those considering suicide

September 18, 2023

Privacy Policy | Your Privacy Options | Notice at Collection | Copyright © 2023 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close

Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.