• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Subscribe
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Leadership
    • Do you know your emotional intelligence?
      Addressing racism in the workplace
      Supervisory actions: Deliberate style or weak skills?
      Are performance evaluations worth the effort?
      Leaders — the good, the bad and the horrible
  • Topics
    • Leadership
      • Do you know your emotional intelligence?
        Addressing racism in the workplace
        Supervisory actions: Deliberate style or weak skills?
        Are performance evaluations worth the effort?
        Leaders — the good, the bad and the horrible
    • Editor’s Picks
      • The future is here
        A winding road
        Do you know your emotional intelligence?
        Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding
        “Hold my beer”
    • On the Job
      • A winding road
        Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding
        I brought home a dog
        Six Mexican cartels designated as terrorist organizations
        Police chief: Officers likely prevented further violence in Minnesota...
    • Labor
      • Building positive media relations
        LEO labor and community outreach — make the haters scoff
        Racing with a purpose
        Dallas Police Department drops college requirement for police...
        Small Texas town left without a police force after firing its last...
    • Tech
      • The future is here
        How local police departments can combat cybercrime
        Your website is your front desk
        Telegram investigations
        Florida sheriff’s office deploys cutting-edge forensic tool to...
    • Training
      • Using critical thinking to crack the case
        Navigating cultural and language barriers
        Why you should pocket carry
        The future is here
        Training for tomorrow
    • Policy
      • California lawmakers push mask ban for officers, raising safety...
        Proactive policing: What it is and how to do it
        California makes police misconduct records publicly available
        A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
        No degree, no badge?
    • Health/Wellness
      • A golden key to suicide prevention
        The urgency to protect those who protect us
        Wellness for warriors: C.O.P.S. can help
        When knowing isn’t enough
        The mindfulness practice of conscious awareness to enhance resilience
    • Community
      • A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
        Operation Brain Freeze keeps community cool
        Turning over a new leaf
        Bridging the Gap Between Cops and Kids
        An unexpected reunion
    • Offbeat
      • Not eggzactly a perfect heist
        Pizza … with a side of alligator?
        Wisconsin man charged with impersonating Border Patrol agent twice in...
        Only in California?
        Durango, Colorado, police hop into action after unusual 9-1-1 call
    • We Remember
      • York County ambush leaves three officers dead, others critically...
        Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
        Team Romeo
        National Police Week 2025
        Honoring Fallen Heroes
    • HOT Mail
      • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • On the Job
    • A winding road
      Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding
      I brought home a dog
      Six Mexican cartels designated as terrorist organizations
      Police chief: Officers likely prevented further violence in Minnesota...
  • Labor
    • Building positive media relations
      LEO labor and community outreach — make the haters scoff
      Racing with a purpose
      Dallas Police Department drops college requirement for police...
      Small Texas town left without a police force after firing its last...
  • Tech
    • The future is here
      How local police departments can combat cybercrime
      Your website is your front desk
      Telegram investigations
      Florida sheriff’s office deploys cutting-edge forensic tool to...
  • Training
    • Using critical thinking to crack the case
      Navigating cultural and language barriers
      Why you should pocket carry
      The future is here
      Training for tomorrow
  • Policy
    • California lawmakers push mask ban for officers, raising safety...
      Proactive policing: What it is and how to do it
      California makes police misconduct records publicly available
      A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
      No degree, no badge?
  • Health/Wellness
    • A golden key to suicide prevention
      The urgency to protect those who protect us
      Wellness for warriors: C.O.P.S. can help
      When knowing isn’t enough
      The mindfulness practice of conscious awareness to enhance resilience
  • Community
    • A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
      Operation Brain Freeze keeps community cool
      Turning over a new leaf
      Bridging the Gap Between Cops and Kids
      An unexpected reunion
  • Offbeat
    • Not eggzactly a perfect heist
      Pizza … with a side of alligator?
      Wisconsin man charged with impersonating Border Patrol agent twice in...
      Only in California?
      Durango, Colorado, police hop into action after unusual 9-1-1 call
  • We Remember
    • York County ambush leaves three officers dead, others critically...
      Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
      Team Romeo
      National Police Week 2025
      Honoring Fallen Heroes
  • HOT Mail
    • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
Search

On the Job

Op-Ed -The police reform challenge: preserving high standards

Paul Cappitelli Published September 23, 2021 @ 9:00 am PDT

iStock.com/kali9

For years, the law enforcement profession has struggled to increase the number of female and minority officers within the ranks. Law enforcement leaders continually beat the drum for diversity and have been doing so for decades. Despite the efforts, the criticism once again is that the lack of diversity is a byproduct of “systemic racism” within the profession. This is a thorny topic of discussion, but it must be addressed. We must acknowledge where there is room for improvement, yet we cannot ignore the fact that challenges have always existed and will continue to plague the efforts.

First and foremost, let me state without question: Racism and discrimination must never be tolerated in any manner in any profession. In a perfect world, every diverse candidate applying to be a police officer gets a job and has a successful career. But the sheer reality of recruitment and vetting is that not everyone meets the qualifications and standards of the profession. This applies to all genders and ethnicities.

The goal of recruiting and retaining diverse police officers is nothing new. What is new is that there now seems to be an emerging trend of making unattainable, virtue-signaling commitments to increase diversity in order to allay the criticism from the zealots. A classic and parallel example is the airline industry. Recently, a major U.S. carrier publicly announced that they intend to ensure that half of their 5,000 new pilots will be women and people of color by 2030. This is a lofty goal and would be a remarkable feat if attainable. The problem is that the airline industry, much like law enforcement, has been recruiting from the candidate pool for years with an eye toward diversity but has not yet been able to reach this quota. Why not? Simply, it’s because the requirements set forth to ensure that the most competent people are hired have always been the primary consideration. This does not imply that diverse candidates are not as qualified as others. It merely indicates that there just aren’t enough competent candidates of all ethnicities and genders to meet the rigorous requirements of being a commercial airline pilot. The industry plans to provide financial assistance to prospective candidates, but many other barriers will continue to exist. 

Each year, thousands of people apply for the job of police officer, yet relatively few are successful. This is not necessarily because of discriminatory practices. It is because the qualifications and training regimen are stringent. Police officers are a lot like airline pilots in that they are entrusted to make decisions that are a matter of life or death. To this end, we must ask ourselves: Do we want the most competent people flying our planes and making decisions in the deployment of deadly force, or do we want the most “diverse” people who may not necessarily be the most competent? In the ideal scenario, we want both, but historically, we have chosen to err on the side of competence. Does society now want diversity to be the preeminent consideration over competency?

The LE profession absolutely needs to be sensitive to the call for diversity. For those agencies that have not made it a priority for whatever reason, the time has come to re-evaluate. Most forward-thinking, larger agencies have had their eye on diversity in hiring for years and have made great progress in this regard. This has always been the goal. Unfortunately, the outcome (i.e., the results of the efforts) are not always in sync with the goals. This is by no fault of their own or for lack of trying. The message would be that the call for diversity is real and present, and every LE agency must give introspection to determine whether they have embraced it or fallen short. Make the adjustments accordingly. However, the LE profession must not cave to the pressure of chasing the quota numbers at the expense of lowering standards or creating disparity within the existing ranks. Everyone must ask themselves: Who do I want to show up to deal with a life-or-death situation when I call the police: the most competent person or the person who was hired to meet a diversity quota? To that end, which pilot do you want in the cockpit of your aircraft?  

Agencies must not allow the push for diversity to undermine the standards and ethos of the LE profession. Try as hard as possible to recruit and retain the best, but know that criticism will always be omnipresent regardless of the effort. It might be a good idea to reach out to faith-based organizations or non-governmental organizations to assist in the diversity effort. If the outcome is not what the critics had hoped for, at least the effort can be accentuated. These are not new challenges, but fresh ideas may help in some small way.

Paul Cappitelli

Paul Cappitelli

APB Columnist Paul Cappitelli is the former executive director for the California Peace Officer's Standards and Training Commission (POST). He provided leadership for the development of visionary training curricula for 80,000+ peace officers. Before that, Paul spent 29 years with the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department retiring as a Captain. His experiences were as a street cop, homicide investigator, first-line supervisor, PIO, training commander and more. He is now a consultant and police practices expert.

View articles by Paul Cappitelli

As seen in the September 2021 issue of American Police Beat magazine.
Don’t miss out on another issue today! Click below:

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

Categories: On the Job

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund launches 2025 Bid for the Badge online auction
  • National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund announces “Restoring the Ranks” conference on recruitment and retention
  • York County ambush leaves three officers dead, others critically wounded
  • California lawmakers push mask ban for officers, raising safety concerns
  • A golden key to suicide prevention
  • Building positive media relations
  • The urgency to protect those who protect us
  • Wellness for warriors: C.O.P.S. can help
  • When knowing isn’t enough
  • Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9/11

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

The future is here

The future is here

August 21, 2025

A winding road

A winding road

August 20, 2025

Do you know your emotional intelligence?

Do you know your emotional intelligence?

August 17, 2025

Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding

Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding

August 11, 2025

Policies | Consent Preferences | Copyright © 2025 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close

Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.