• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Subscribe
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Leadership
    • A candid chat with law enforcement Explorer scouts
      Do you know your emotional intelligence?
      Addressing racism in the workplace
      Supervisory actions: Deliberate style or weak skills?
      Are performance evaluations worth the effort?
  • Topics
    • Leadership
      • A candid chat with law enforcement Explorer scouts
        Do you know your emotional intelligence?
        Addressing racism in the workplace
        Supervisory actions: Deliberate style or weak skills?
        Are performance evaluations worth the effort?
    • Editor’s Picks
      • The future is here
        A winding road
        Do you know your emotional intelligence?
        Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding
        “Hold my beer”
    • On the Job
      • A winding road
        Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding
        I brought home a dog
        Six Mexican cartels designated as terrorist organizations
        Police chief: Officers likely prevented further violence in Minnesota...
    • Labor
      • Building positive media relations
        LEO labor and community outreach — make the haters scoff
        Racing with a purpose
        Dallas Police Department drops college requirement for police...
        Small Texas town left without a police force after firing its last...
    • Tech
      • New Jersey school district first to adopt AI gun detection and...
        Hawaii police harness virtual reality technology to train, secure and...
        The future is here
        How local police departments can combat cybercrime
        Your website is your front desk
    • Training
      • Training dipshittery
        Police Academy 20
        Using critical thinking to crack the case
        Navigating cultural and language barriers
        Why you should pocket carry
    • Policy
      • Consolidation in action
        California lawmakers push mask ban for officers, raising safety...
        Proactive policing: What it is and how to do it
        California makes police misconduct records publicly available
        A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
    • Health/Wellness
      • Time and distance
        Meditation is hard because it’s not what you think
        Life off the clock
        Self-help for anxiety
        The warm path and the hot path
    • Community
      • A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
        Operation Brain Freeze keeps community cool
        Turning over a new leaf
        Bridging the Gap Between Cops and Kids
        An unexpected reunion
    • Offbeat
      • Not eggzactly a perfect heist
        Pizza … with a side of alligator?
        Wisconsin man charged with impersonating Border Patrol agent twice in...
        Only in California?
        Durango, Colorado, police hop into action after unusual 9-1-1 call
    • We Remember
      • York County ambush leaves three officers dead, others critically...
        Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
        Team Romeo
        National Police Week 2025
        Honoring Fallen Heroes
    • HOT Mail
      • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • On the Job
    • A winding road
      Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding
      I brought home a dog
      Six Mexican cartels designated as terrorist organizations
      Police chief: Officers likely prevented further violence in Minnesota...
  • Labor
    • Building positive media relations
      LEO labor and community outreach — make the haters scoff
      Racing with a purpose
      Dallas Police Department drops college requirement for police...
      Small Texas town left without a police force after firing its last...
  • Tech
    • New Jersey school district first to adopt AI gun detection and...
      Hawaii police harness virtual reality technology to train, secure and...
      The future is here
      How local police departments can combat cybercrime
      Your website is your front desk
  • Training
    • Training dipshittery
      Police Academy 20
      Using critical thinking to crack the case
      Navigating cultural and language barriers
      Why you should pocket carry
  • Policy
    • Consolidation in action
      California lawmakers push mask ban for officers, raising safety...
      Proactive policing: What it is and how to do it
      California makes police misconduct records publicly available
      A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
  • Health/Wellness
    • Time and distance
      Meditation is hard because it’s not what you think
      Life off the clock
      Self-help for anxiety
      The warm path and the hot path
  • Community
    • A bold idea for reducing homelessness in America
      Operation Brain Freeze keeps community cool
      Turning over a new leaf
      Bridging the Gap Between Cops and Kids
      An unexpected reunion
  • Offbeat
    • Not eggzactly a perfect heist
      Pizza … with a side of alligator?
      Wisconsin man charged with impersonating Border Patrol agent twice in...
      Only in California?
      Durango, Colorado, police hop into action after unusual 9-1-1 call
  • We Remember
    • York County ambush leaves three officers dead, others critically...
      Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
      Team Romeo
      National Police Week 2025
      Honoring Fallen Heroes
  • HOT Mail
    • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
Search

Policy

Utah case reignites debate on “shooting not to kill”

APB Team Published December 23, 2021 @ 6:00 am PST

Enoch City Police Officer Jeremy Dunn points his gun at Ivonne Casimiro after shooting her in the knee on June 29, 2018. Dunn told investigators he purposely shot Casimiro in the leg to save her life. She survived and is now in prison. (Enoch City Police Department)

A Utah police shooting reignited a debate around “shooting not to kill” — an issue that frustrates many in the law enforcement community.

The case in question regarded a 2018 encounter between two Enoch City police officers and a man and woman accused of breaking into cars. The woman was armed with a screwdriver. After repeatedly refusing to put down the weapon, Officer Jeremy Dunn used his Taser on her, but she was unaffected and simply removed the wires. So, he decided to shoot to incapacitate.

“Do you want me to take her out like last time?” Dunn asked then-Sergeant Mike Berg. He was referring to the time he shot a suicidal man in the leg in 2012. When the woman, Ivonne Casimiro, took a step toward the officers, Dunn opened fire, hitting Casimiro in the knee.

She survived and eventually pleaded guilty to assault against a police officer and driving a stolen car. She is currently in prison.

However, following an internal investigation, Dunn was terminated from his job and was barred from working as a police officer for the next four years. The Utah Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) board reviewed the case and determined that the shooting was not legally justified because Casimiro was not an imminent threat.

However, the review also found that the Enoch City Police Department did not have a rule against officers shooting with the intent to incapacitate.

A question has been floated often by civilians who wonder why officers do not “shoot not to kill” more often by instead aiming for the extremities in order to incapacitate a person. It’s a question that irks many in the law enforcement community.

Most officers agree that situations like Dunn’s are rare in that officers usually do not have as much time to make a decision or to aim so precisely.

Salt Lake City Police Deputy Chief Scott Mourtgos told PBS Frontline that civilians’ expectations for an officer to consistently hit “precision shots” at someone’s leg or arm is “unrealistic.” In addition, it puts officers and the public in greater danger when an officer misses those shots.

Federal Way Police Chief Deputy Kyle Sumpter told Police1: “When an armed attack is underway, any response less than deadly force is wishful thinking, a hope-for-the-best reliance on the assailant’s good faith or luck.”

Police academies train cadets to aim for a person’s center-mass in order to quickly eliminate the threat. However, some argue that shooting to incapacitate may have its place in today’s police climate after nearly 17% of the 1,115 people killed by police over the last five years were armed with edged weapons.

Indeed, the LaGrange, Georgia, Police Department is one of the first to recognize a place for shooting to incapacitate in policing. The department is one of the first in the country to institute a specific training program dealing with this issue based on European guidelines where police deal with fewer guns and more edged and blunt weapons during a call.

However, Mourtgos argued that shooting to incapacitate won’t necessarily prevent someone from dying.

“I’ve seen people survive being shot in the head with a bullet … I’ve seen people die from being shot in the leg and arm,” Mourtgos said. “There is no good place to shoot a human being.”

Finally, Utah POST director Major Scott Stephenson said that while such a policy would result in fewer deaths, it would simply be because “officers will frequently miss their intended target” — referring to their legs.

The trade-off, he added, is an increased risk to the public, arguing such a practice “could jeopardize innocent bystanders at a higher rate.” 

As seen in the December 2021 issue of American Police Beat magazine.
Don’t miss out on another issue today! Click below:

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

Categories: Policy

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • NLEOMF thanks supporters for a successful Police Weekend
  • Training dipshittery
  • Time and distance
  • Meditation is hard because it’s not what you think
  • Police Academy 20
  • Life off the clock
  • Self-help for anxiety
  • National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund Announces August 2025 Officers of the Month
  • Justice Federal Credit Union stands ready to offer members special assistance in the event of a federal government shutdown
  • New Jersey school district first to adopt AI gun detection and emergency alerts

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

The future is here

The future is here

August 21, 2025

A winding road

A winding road

August 20, 2025

Do you know your emotional intelligence?

Do you know your emotional intelligence?

August 17, 2025

Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding

Law enforcement responds to tragic Texas flooding

August 11, 2025

Policies | Consent Preferences | Copyright © 2025 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close

Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.