• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Subscribe
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Leadership
    • The measure of a mentor
      Developing a leadership framework
      When nothing happens: The invisible work of effective police...
      The most important person is the captain
      Every great sports team has a playbook
  • Topics
    • Leadership
      • The measure of a mentor
        Developing a leadership framework
        When nothing happens: The invisible work of effective police...
        The most important person is the captain
        Every great sports team has a playbook
    • Editor’s Picks
      • More than just a red shirt and a Sharpie
        The sixth sense in policing
        Train them to ask why
        The shift happens long before the resignation letter
        No two days are ever the same
    • On the Job
      • Domestic violence calls
        Human trafficking: The hidden criminal enterprise
        A winning sign
        LAPD puts brakes on bike takeover
        Frankpledge to forensics: A brief history of law enforcement
    • Labor
      • The shift happens long before the resignation letter
        Facing the oral board
        Why good cops quit
        Succession planning
        Why more staff won’t fix your operational slowdowns
    • Tech
      • Video can be your portable coach
        Accentuating safety for first responders
        Take Me Home program offers effective tool for police and families
        Get the most out of simulation training
        The virtual beat
    • Training
      • The shotgun revival
        When SWAT isn’t coming anytime soon
        Leading through the crucible
        How small departments can prepare for rural disasters
        Do your metrics tell the wrong story?
    • Policy
      • Policy should guide, not handcuff
        Out of chaos comes opportunity
        Massachusetts law establishes fund to care for retired K-9s
        Portlanders will not vote on diverting climate funds for police...
        Surviving internal affairs investigations
    • Health/Wellness
      • After the shift: A police officer’s dreams
        Successful strategies for police handling of mental health-related...
        Permission to play
        The call you handled right can still hurt you
        The radio says you’re clear; your body disagrees
    • Community
      • Inspiring noteworthy community outreach
        A happier homecoming
        National Night Out 2026
        Pittsburgh mounted patrol officer helps inner-city kids saddle up
        Wyoming girl on a mission to collect “hero patches”
    • Offbeat
      • Snagging a grilled snake
        A surprise sting operation
        Could cadaver otters help close cold cases?
        Police chief catches cat in the act
        “Teenage Mutant Ninja Deer” rescued
    • We Remember
      • Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9-11
        Steel Across America
        The first officers on scene on September 11
        Protecting America with the USA PATRIOT Act
        Distant cousins connect to honor fallen family member 110 years after...
    • HOT Mail
      • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • On the Job
    • Domestic violence calls
      Human trafficking: The hidden criminal enterprise
      A winning sign
      LAPD puts brakes on bike takeover
      Frankpledge to forensics: A brief history of law enforcement
  • Labor
    • The shift happens long before the resignation letter
      Facing the oral board
      Why good cops quit
      Succession planning
      Why more staff won’t fix your operational slowdowns
  • Tech
    • Video can be your portable coach
      Accentuating safety for first responders
      Take Me Home program offers effective tool for police and families
      Get the most out of simulation training
      The virtual beat
  • Training
    • The shotgun revival
      When SWAT isn’t coming anytime soon
      Leading through the crucible
      How small departments can prepare for rural disasters
      Do your metrics tell the wrong story?
  • Policy
    • Policy should guide, not handcuff
      Out of chaos comes opportunity
      Massachusetts law establishes fund to care for retired K-9s
      Portlanders will not vote on diverting climate funds for police...
      Surviving internal affairs investigations
  • Health/Wellness
    • After the shift: A police officer’s dreams
      Successful strategies for police handling of mental health-related...
      Permission to play
      The call you handled right can still hurt you
      The radio says you’re clear; your body disagrees
  • Community
    • Inspiring noteworthy community outreach
      A happier homecoming
      National Night Out 2026
      Pittsburgh mounted patrol officer helps inner-city kids saddle up
      Wyoming girl on a mission to collect “hero patches”
  • Offbeat
    • Snagging a grilled snake
      A surprise sting operation
      Could cadaver otters help close cold cases?
      Police chief catches cat in the act
      “Teenage Mutant Ninja Deer” rescued
  • We Remember
    • Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9-11
      Steel Across America
      The first officers on scene on September 11
      Protecting America with the USA PATRIOT Act
      Distant cousins connect to honor fallen family member 110 years after...
  • HOT Mail
    • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
Search

Leadership

Leading from the bottom up

To prevent a leadership void at the top, training and expectations should start at entry level

Todd Fletcher Published July 17, 2023 @ 6:00 am PDT

Ron Taylor, Combative Firearms Training, LLC

Officers, first-line supervisors and trainers often lament the lack of leadership in law enforcement. They look at their department’s command staff and point toward the top of the rank structure as the area with the leadership void. They look at their department’s top management positions and complain about the lack of leadership at the highest ranks. And guess what? They’re not wrong. 

Nationwide, there is a tremendous lack of leadership in law enforcement command staff personnel. But that lack of leadership and the resulting problems started at the officer, trainer and first-line supervisor level. Very few, if any, chiefs of police, sheriffs, chief deputies, undersheriffs, majors or captains came into this career with the intent to be a poor leader. It started early in their careers.

Ineffective leaders at the top

All too frequently, when we talk about leadership, we focus on the top of the chain-of-command pyramid. Many people think about the chiefs, sheriffs, captains, majors and other high-ranking officials. This is the group that trots out on stage in front of the cameras after something goes terribly wrong. They play the role of politician perfectly — filled with righteous indignation and demands to get to the bottom of things. This same group is also highly visible before elections when voters decide on funding measures or candidates. When these folks are on television, I guarantee it’s bad news. When was the last time you saw a chief of police calling a press conference to praise officers for all the positive contacts they had with the community? I have all day. I’ll wait….

It’s easy to point the finger at this group, because they occupy the top positions in our departments. Since there’s only one chief of police or sheriff, they stand out. Everything they do is magnified by the media, the community and the people of their department. They say it’s lonely at the top, and I’m sure it is a very difficult position. No one should believe for a minute that leading a law enforcement agency is a simple task.

While it’s true those in these positions hold the ultimate positions of authority within a law enforcement agency, their failings are symptomatic of a much deeper problem. Even the worst chief I ever worked for never made it his career goal to be a bad chief. As a matter of fact, when he was a sergeant, those who worked for him spoke about how he supported his officers, sought training opportunities for his team and was an active member on patrol. However, when he became a captain, his hunger for promotion was obvious as he chose politics over people. He was nice to your face but would stab you in the back if you voiced an opinion that differed from his. In hindsight, his failings didn’t start when he became a captain. They started much earlier in his career, when there were few, if any, leadership expectations at lower ranks.

Dreamstime.com/Mediaonela

An institutional problem

As a profession, we should have leadership expectations and training at the entry-level positions. Most sergeants and lieutenants in law enforcement don’t attend formal leadership training until after they are selected as supervisors. How is this even possible? Why do we select new supervisors, and expect them to be some of the most influential leaders within our departments, without providing leadership training and opportunities before promotion? How do we know what we’ll get once they’re promoted? This is a problem with a simple solution. We should have leadership training opportunities and leadership expectations for every rank in our agencies from day one.

Every police academy should include leadership opportunities and expectations for all cadets. Even if someone doesn’t hold a formal position of rank, we need to have leadership expectations of every single cadet. When they pin on the badge and fasten the duty belt around their waist for their first day on patrol, our communities expect them to present themselves and perform as leaders. At a minimum, we should have the same expectations.

Once they graduate from the academy and hit the streets, field training officers and supervisors need to have leadership expectations of those new officers. Even in field training, they look like police officers, dress like police officers and have the same responsibilities as every other law enforcement officer in the department. They have the authority and responsibility to use reasonable force to take people into custody without their consent, and the ability to change people’s conduct by just being present. This is a heavy responsibility for anyone, let alone a young adult between 21 and 29 years of age. 

When we demand leadership in our hiring processes, our basic academy training and our field training programs, we can set the tone and expectations for an officer’s entire career. Without demanding leadership traits, establishing leadership expectations and promoting leadership values, we shouldn’t be surprised when cops do things because they become badge-heavy. However, strong leadership and leadership expectations can help prevent bad behavior from occurring within our ranks. Bad behavior from one casts a stain on us all.

Own the problem

I know a lot of officers are still pointing fingers at the top and thinking, “But if we had a chief who was a good leader, then we wouldn’t have these problems.” True or not, that’s a weak excuse for failing to take action where you have the most influence. During an interview, Brian Willis from Winning Mind Training put it very plainly: “The majority of law enforcement officers are sergeants on down. When officers, deputies, agents, constables, troopers, corporals and sergeants become the leaders and change agents of the department, it makes bad leadership at the command staff level nearly irrelevant.”

We may not want to admit it, but once again, if we have leadership training opportunities and expectations at the bottom of the chain-of-command pyramid, we can overcome bad leadership at the top. Ask yourself this: how many chiefs or sheriffs have influence over patrol briefings? In the 16 years I served as a sergeant, I can count on one hand the number of times the chief attended a patrol briefing — and when he did, it was a quick appearance rather than being an active participant. However, the sergeant, corporals and officers have tremendous influence on every single briefing. Strong leadership from those positions influences the quality of information, shift goals and overall attitude of the team.

I started my firearms training company in 2011 with a focus on law enforcement, private security and military instructors. The classroom session of every class on day one includes a PowerPoint slide that states, “Arguably the biggest problem facing law enforcement is lack of leadership.” Unfortunately, 12 years later, that slide is still as relevant as ever. One could even argue that it’s more relevant than ever, considering recent incidents that shine a light on the problems that can arise when a department lacks leadership. On the other hand, good leadership can improve a department and help prevent those types of serious problems. As anyone who has attended our classes can attest, I believe the best firearm instructors are also great leaders. There’s no getting around this simple fact: a good teacher, coach, mentor and instructor possesses good leadership skills. 

Last year, I experienced a prime example of this concept during one of our Pistol-Mounted Optics Instructor classes. The class started in the classroom and included a presentation on instructional leadership. Unbeknownst to me, one of the students later complained to another student about the leadership portion, saying he was there to learn about teaching the transition to optics from iron sights and not for a lecture about leadership. If he had the courage to say this during class, I would have pointed out that adding an optic to a pistol doubles the cost of the handgun and requires additional time and money for training. There are also some officers who are resistant to the change. Dealing with these issues requires leadership. And, if he still didn’t understand the connection between being an instructor and being a leader, I would have pointed out that he was the reason those slides are included, because he was an example of the problem. Leadership is an issue in our profession long before someone is promoted to the upper command ranks.

The chief I mentioned earlier did not have leadership training or expectations early in his career. If he had, maybe he would have been a good leader. Maybe not. As a profession, we can’t continue down the path of terrible leadership. We are in the lifesaving business. Law enforcement is too important to our communities, our states and our nation to put the political drones in front of the camera when things go bad. Let’s lead from the bottom up to save our noble profession.

Todd Fletcher

Todd Fletcher

Todd Fletcher is a retired sergeant from central Oregon with over 30 years of law enforcement experience. He presents firearms training, instructor certification and instructor development classes nationwide. Todd has presented at multiple regional, national and international conferences, including multiple ILEETA conferences and IALEFI events. He owns Combative Firearms Training, LLC, providing firearms training, handgun and patrol rifle instructor certification, and instructor development classes to law enforcement, military and private security. He can be contacted at Todd@CombativeFirearms.com.

View articles by Todd Fletcher

As seen in the July 2023 issue of American Police Beat magazine.
Don’t miss out on another issue today! Click below:

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

Categories: Leadership, Training

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • Domestic violence calls
  • The shotgun revival
  • When SWAT isn’t coming anytime soon
  • The measure of a mentor
  • Human trafficking: The hidden criminal enterprise
  • Snagging a grilled snake
  • National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund announces September 2026 Officers of the Month
  • A winning sign
  • Developing a leadership framework
  • Leading through the crucible

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

More than just a red shirt and a Sharpie

More than just a red shirt and a Sharpie

August 22, 2026

The sixth sense in policing

The sixth sense in policing

August 21, 2026

Train them to ask why

Train them to ask why

August 19, 2026

The shift happens long before the resignation letter

The shift happens long before the resignation letter

August 16, 2026

Policies | Consent Preferences | Copyright © 2026 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close

Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.