• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Subscribe
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Leadership
    • The danger of directionless leadership
      The measure of a mentor
      Developing a leadership framework
      When nothing happens: The invisible work of effective police...
      The most important person is the captain
  • Topics
    • Leadership
      • The danger of directionless leadership
        The measure of a mentor
        Developing a leadership framework
        When nothing happens: The invisible work of effective police...
        The most important person is the captain
    • Editor’s Picks
      • More than just a red shirt and a Sharpie
        The sixth sense in policing
        Train them to ask why
        The shift happens long before the resignation letter
        No two days are ever the same
    • On the Job
      • Domestic violence calls
        Human trafficking: The hidden criminal enterprise
        A winning sign
        LAPD puts brakes on bike takeover
        Frankpledge to forensics: A brief history of law enforcement
    • Labor
      • Building a wall of trust
        The shift happens long before the resignation letter
        Facing the oral board
        Why good cops quit
        Succession planning
    • Tech
      • Video can be your portable coach
        Accentuating safety for first responders
        Take Me Home program offers effective tool for police and families
        Get the most out of simulation training
        The virtual beat
    • Training
      • The shotgun revival
        When SWAT isn’t coming anytime soon
        Leading through the crucible
        How small departments can prepare for rural disasters
        Do your metrics tell the wrong story?
    • Policy
      • Policy should guide, not handcuff
        Out of chaos comes opportunity
        Massachusetts law establishes fund to care for retired K-9s
        Portlanders will not vote on diverting climate funds for police...
        Surviving internal affairs investigations
    • Health/Wellness
      • Beyond resilience
        After the shift: A police officer’s dreams
        Successful strategies for police handling of mental health-related...
        Permission to play
        The call you handled right can still hurt you
    • Community
      • Inspiring noteworthy community outreach
        A happier homecoming
        National Night Out 2026
        Pittsburgh mounted patrol officer helps inner-city kids saddle up
        Wyoming girl on a mission to collect “hero patches”
    • Offbeat
      • Snagging a grilled snake
        A surprise sting operation
        Could cadaver otters help close cold cases?
        Police chief catches cat in the act
        “Teenage Mutant Ninja Deer” rescued
    • We Remember
      • Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9-11
        Steel Across America
        The first officers on scene on September 11
        Protecting America with the USA PATRIOT Act
        Distant cousins connect to honor fallen family member 110 years after...
    • HOT Mail
      • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • On the Job
    • Domestic violence calls
      Human trafficking: The hidden criminal enterprise
      A winning sign
      LAPD puts brakes on bike takeover
      Frankpledge to forensics: A brief history of law enforcement
  • Labor
    • Building a wall of trust
      The shift happens long before the resignation letter
      Facing the oral board
      Why good cops quit
      Succession planning
  • Tech
    • Video can be your portable coach
      Accentuating safety for first responders
      Take Me Home program offers effective tool for police and families
      Get the most out of simulation training
      The virtual beat
  • Training
    • The shotgun revival
      When SWAT isn’t coming anytime soon
      Leading through the crucible
      How small departments can prepare for rural disasters
      Do your metrics tell the wrong story?
  • Policy
    • Policy should guide, not handcuff
      Out of chaos comes opportunity
      Massachusetts law establishes fund to care for retired K-9s
      Portlanders will not vote on diverting climate funds for police...
      Surviving internal affairs investigations
  • Health/Wellness
    • Beyond resilience
      After the shift: A police officer’s dreams
      Successful strategies for police handling of mental health-related...
      Permission to play
      The call you handled right can still hurt you
  • Community
    • Inspiring noteworthy community outreach
      A happier homecoming
      National Night Out 2026
      Pittsburgh mounted patrol officer helps inner-city kids saddle up
      Wyoming girl on a mission to collect “hero patches”
  • Offbeat
    • Snagging a grilled snake
      A surprise sting operation
      Could cadaver otters help close cold cases?
      Police chief catches cat in the act
      “Teenage Mutant Ninja Deer” rescued
  • We Remember
    • Honoring the Fallen Heroes of 9-11
      Steel Across America
      The first officers on scene on September 11
      Protecting America with the USA PATRIOT Act
      Distant cousins connect to honor fallen family member 110 years after...
  • HOT Mail
    • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
Search

Leadership

How not to fail as an outside chief

In 15 easy steps

Keith Bushey Published June 27, 2025 @ 5:28 pm PDT

iStock.com/Jerome Maurice

It is easy to say and do the wrong things as a leader, and as a new chief “coming in from the outside,” it is particularly easy to make mistakes from which recovery can be difficult. The following recommendations are guaranteed to keep the new chief in the new agency longer than would otherwise have occurred had these issues not been considered.

Do not talk too much

No truer words were ever spoken than the quote attributed to Abraham Lincoln, “It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open one’s mouth and remove all doubt!” Also, be reminded of the reality that silence conveys the impression of thoughtful contemplation. Be an active listener and learn as much and gain as many perspectives as possible. Excessive verbalization is tough for some people and should be consciously avoided.

Do not fail to be conspicuous

Everybody will have a perspective on the new boss, whether true, false or misunderstood. Be immediately conspicuous throughout the organization in a friendly and professional manner. To the predictable requests and suggestions for everything from the budget to promotions and reorganizations, listen carefully, be grateful for the input and commit to nothing. Your conspicuousness will start the process of your folks making their own judgments about your personal and professional qualities.

Do not fail to develop an effective staff

You must have the ability to maintain an essential flow of accurate required information. While recognizing that changes may be made to your immediate staff, you need to do whatever necessary to address critical issues. Using a proficient typist to whom you can dictate can be a force multiplier.

Do not fail to communicate department-wide

In the absence of a conscious and deliberate effort, department-wide intended information will be distorted, whether accidentally or intentionally. There are only three ways to ensure the accurate provision of information: in writing, via video or face to face with the intended recipient. Typically, written communications are the most practical. Keep two things in mind: verbal information is always distorted as it goes from person to person, and if it is not in writing, it did not occur.

Do not seek measures to “improve morale”

Do not look for some token measure that might be perceived as a morale booster; in time, the short-lived appreciation will be forgotten, and the action will be seen as a superficial gesture. The only “magic bullet” for good morale is solid leadership.

Do not seek or develop close relationships with employees

You may be absolutely assured that the workplace and some of the employees will be seen in a different manner after you have been in place for several months. Resist the temptation to develop close relationships that may unduly influence decisions, assignments and promotions. Everybody has an opinion about everyone else, and it is easy to fall into the trap of quickly developing confidence in one or two individuals who in turn may influence you in making decisions that reflect their perspectives. Listen to everyone, reflect on all that you perceive, let a reasonable amount of time pass, then make decisions that reflect your genuine best judgments.

Do not seek or develop close relationships with public officials

Developing a close relationship with someone such as a mayor, city manager or councilperson can be (and usually is!) today’s solution and tomorrow’s nightmare. It is a reality that public officials frequently disagree with one another, often leave office and find themselves under attack for any number of reasons. Being overly cozy with one public official is often at the expense of another, plus they will eventually move on. When you do something that is unpopular, it may be seen as a personal affront. Two political realities are worthy of constant awareness: popularity is related to political agreement, and closeness with one person often comes with the reality of dislike by their political enemies.

Do not believe all that you are told

Every employee has an opinion about any number of things and will be happy to share those perspectives with the new boss. Listen, learn (maybe!) and reflect on all that you hear and are told before ultimately forming your own perspectives. While it is probably a bit harsh, a wise person may be well advised to believe nothing that is spoken or written, and only half of what is observed!

Do not immediately start changing things

Ultimate change is almost always inevitable, but it must be the consequence of circumstances and thoughtful reflection. For the most part, things are done a certain way for appropriate reasons. A new boss needs to resist the temptation to make changes until there is an understanding of the issues and reasons why things are being done in the present manner. Otherwise, you may be fixing things that are not broken and ultimately revert to the initial approach. Additionally, a new boss who immediately starts changing things comes across as impulsive and amateurish.

Do not prematurely embrace community leaders

Every public safety executive has as a key goal finding the true leaders and centers of gravity of our communities and being able to develop and maintain a mutually advantageous relationship to promote public safety. This is often a very difficult task! It is not unusual for a person to falsely assert a position of community leadership and claim to be the key person in representing the residents or businesses. This is seldom completely accurate, as very few communities are truly that organized, and it is not unusual for a well-intended person to represent only a small number of residents in a neighborhood. There are also many (too many) instances where a person who claims to be a community leader does so for selfish or illegal reasons. Listen, learn and be polite to everyone until you identify those with good intentions and reasonable followership.

Do not immediately make promotions or critical assignments

The new boss may be able to fill a promotional or assignment vacancy, and it is likely that several people will subtly try to influence the selection, either for themselves or another person. Resist the temptation and the often strong influences to make permanent personnel decisions until a solid understanding and assessment of all eligible candidates is understood.

Do not ignore the community

Get to know the community by going directly to the businesses, churches, schools and organizations. This creates the opportunity for mutual understandings of respective concerns and is unfiltered by persons claiming positions of leadership. You also may awaken some great people who will move into community leadership positions.

Do not unnecessarily mention previous agencies

There is always concern within an agency that an outside chief will try to convert the new agency into the mold of the former organization. Do not give credence to such an impression by unnecessarily referring to where you came from. In discussing past strategies, etc., use expressions such as “among my previous experiences was…” or similar verbiage.

Do not prematurely discuss detailed intentions and concerns

While taking seriously and certainly not disregarding things that you have been told about your new agency, do not accept as gospel anything you have been told until you have personally validated the situation. There are few faster pathways to disaster than going into an agency, fixing things that are not broken and dealing harshly with decent people who were doing well.

Do not fail to establish an immediate understanding with potential problem subordinates

Leopards do not change their spots, and people who undermine others do not change either. Do not think that your smiles, handshakes and wonderful personality are going to change someone who is likely to undermine you. Early on, go behind closed doors and make it abundantly clear what you see as an unacceptable likelihood and exactly what you expect in terms of support and spirit, leaving no room for misunderstanding. Document your concerns with a copy for each employee and inform the city manager of your actions. 

In summary, I cannot predict how long you will remain in your new position, but I promise that it will be longer than it would otherwise have been had you not taken these 15 suggestions seriously.

Keith Bushey

Keith Bushey

Keith Bushey retired from the Los Angeles Police Department as a commander, from the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department as a deputy chief and from the United States Marine Corps Reserve as a colonel. Other law enforcement experience includes having served as a Los Angeles County deputy sheriff, a state of California deputy game warden and the marshal of San Bernardino County. He is an instructor emeritus for the FBI Law Enforcement Executive Development Association and has lectured and written extensively in the areas of leadership, management and ethics. His entire eight-booklet Leadership Series is in the public domain and may be downloaded without cost from KeithBushey.com. He may be contacted at kdbs255@aol.com.

View articles by Keith Bushey

As seen in the June 2025 issue of American Police Beat magazine.
Don’t miss out on another issue today! Click below:

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

Categories: Leadership

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • The danger of directionless leadership
  • Building a wall of trust
  • Beyond resilience
  • Domestic violence calls
  • The shotgun revival
  • When SWAT isn’t coming anytime soon
  • The measure of a mentor
  • Human trafficking: The hidden criminal enterprise
  • Snagging a grilled snake
  • National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund announces September 2026 Officers of the Month

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

More than just a red shirt and a Sharpie

More than just a red shirt and a Sharpie

August 22, 2026

The sixth sense in policing

The sixth sense in policing

August 21, 2026

Train them to ask why

Train them to ask why

August 19, 2026

The shift happens long before the resignation letter

The shift happens long before the resignation letter

August 16, 2026

Policies | Consent Preferences | Copyright © 2026 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close

Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.