• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Subscribe to the Magazine
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Editor’s Picks
    • The power of teamwork
      Stay awake and alert on the job
      The worst rank in law enforcement
      Firearms maintenance
      Why fries need salt
  • Topics
    • On the Job
      • Tucson tries new tact to fight crime
        2022 Top Cops
        Pennsylvania siblings embark on law enforcement career together
        Massachusetts school resource officer honored for saving choking girl
        Phoenix police recover over 1,000 catalytic converters in huge bust
    • Labor
      • Philadelphia may rehire officers and civilian employees to fill...
        Chicago police recruit Marines to help address officer shortage
        Illinois State Police announce lateral training program with added...
        The “great resignation” brings staffing troubles to Missouri law...
        NYPD overtime expected to surpass budget by over $142 million to...
    • Tech
      • Local law enforcement agencies learn to recover stolen cryptocurrency
        New York mayor proposes gun detection scanners after rise in subway...
        Hacker group steals data from multiple law enforcement data systems...
        Illinois police unveil new technology, more body cameras to promote...
        High-tech policing
    • Training
      • An equation for performing lawful Terry stops
        A Connecticut police chief says his department needs more drug...
        “The hidden danger is the water”
        Weapon retention
        Developing trauma-informed training and drills for K–12 schools
    • Policy
      • Putting the brakes on wandering cops
        Detroit police team up with federal law enforcement agencies to fight...
        Police driving practices under review as fatalities, injuries caused...
        Law enforcement leaders meet to discuss major public safety issues...
        New York mayor proposes gun detection scanners after rise in subway...
    • Health/Wellness
      • True detectives: Psychological realities of investigative work
        Effective use of chaplain services
        Things I learned as a retiree
        Normalization of deviance
        The nobility of policing
    • Community
      • Crime problems are community problems
        Texas law enforcement agencies show their support to Uvalde in wake...
        Pennsylvania girl celebrates 10th birthday fundraising for New...
        Jiu-Jitsu practitioner helps deputy subdue wanted man
        “We always know that our citizens have our back”:
    • Offbeat
      • Only in Florida: Police snipers provide backup during...
        Longtime Maryland con man arrested for impersonating U.S. marshal
        Seattle cancels and refunds seven months of parking tickets due to...
        Wisconsin police focus on emergency K-9 medical treatment in new...
        Romance novelist who wrote essay titled “How to Murder Your...
    • We Remember
      • Memorializing our fallen sisters
        Paying Tribute to Fallen Heroes
        National Law Enforcement Memorial expands to accommodate more names
        National Police Week
        “It’s not enough to never forget anymore”
  • On the Job
    • Tucson tries new tact to fight crime
      2022 Top Cops
      Pennsylvania siblings embark on law enforcement career together
      Massachusetts school resource officer honored for saving choking girl
      Phoenix police recover over 1,000 catalytic converters in huge bust
  • Labor
    • Philadelphia may rehire officers and civilian employees to fill...
      Chicago police recruit Marines to help address officer shortage
      Illinois State Police announce lateral training program with added...
      The “great resignation” brings staffing troubles to Missouri law...
      NYPD overtime expected to surpass budget by over $142 million to...
  • Tech
    • Local law enforcement agencies learn to recover stolen cryptocurrency
      New York mayor proposes gun detection scanners after rise in subway...
      Hacker group steals data from multiple law enforcement data systems...
      Illinois police unveil new technology, more body cameras to promote...
      High-tech policing
  • Training
    • An equation for performing lawful Terry stops
      A Connecticut police chief says his department needs more drug...
      “The hidden danger is the water”
      Weapon retention
      Developing trauma-informed training and drills for K–12 schools
  • Policy
    • Putting the brakes on wandering cops
      Detroit police team up with federal law enforcement agencies to fight...
      Police driving practices under review as fatalities, injuries caused...
      Law enforcement leaders meet to discuss major public safety issues...
      New York mayor proposes gun detection scanners after rise in subway...
  • Health/Wellness
    • True detectives: Psychological realities of investigative work
      Effective use of chaplain services
      Things I learned as a retiree
      Normalization of deviance
      The nobility of policing
  • Community
    • Crime problems are community problems
      Texas law enforcement agencies show their support to Uvalde in wake...
      Pennsylvania girl celebrates 10th birthday fundraising for New...
      Jiu-Jitsu practitioner helps deputy subdue wanted man
      “We always know that our citizens have our back”:
  • Offbeat
    • Only in Florida: Police snipers provide backup during...
      Longtime Maryland con man arrested for impersonating U.S. marshal
      Seattle cancels and refunds seven months of parking tickets due to...
      Wisconsin police focus on emergency K-9 medical treatment in new...
      Romance novelist who wrote essay titled “How to Murder Your...
  • We Remember
    • Memorializing our fallen sisters
      Paying Tribute to Fallen Heroes
      National Law Enforcement Memorial expands to accommodate more names
      National Police Week
      “It’s not enough to never forget anymore”
  • Between the Lines
    • Persecution of the LEO is Classic Schadenfreude
      The Rule of Law is Worthless Without Order
      School policing: a paradox of the defund movement
      Defending the honor of the LE profession – finally!
      The dichotomy of the defund movement: reality setting in
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Search

Policy

New York court suspends familial DNA searching by law enforcement

APB Team Published May 17, 2022 @ 3:00 pm PDT

iStock.com/ktsimage

A New York court recently ruled to suspend familial DNA searching by law enforcement — a technique allowed by state executive powers — because it was never approved by the state legislature.

Familial DNA searching refers to searching for biological relatives of individuals whose genetic material was found at a crime scene and stored in a DNA databank.

The search technique has allowed law enforcement agencies to crack cold cases and track down murderers, but a panel of judges in a midlevel court have struck it down, arguing on the basis of privacy and racial discrimination concerns, and that regulations were never authorized by state lawmakers.

Three out of five judges voted to suspend the practice after a lawsuit was filed by a group of Black men who were worried that they could be targeted by law enforcement if their biological relatives convicted of crimes had genetic information stored in a DNA database.

In her majority opinion, Judge Judith J. Gische said the decision was based on concerns about government separation of powers after regulations on using the state’s DNA databank were issued in 2017 by New York’s Division of Criminal Justice Services, part of the state’s executive branch, and the independent Commission on Forensic Science.

Gische noted that familial DNA searching was a useful law enforcement tool that previously led to California and Kansas police identifying serial killers.

“We find that the overwhelming policy issues inherent in authorizing the use and limitations upon familial match searches of DNA information collected in the New York State databank warrant a conclusion that it is an inherently legislative function and that the challenged regulation cannot stand,” Gische wrote.

The ruling will only restrict law enforcement’s use of the state’s DNA databank, which contains samples of people convicted of crimes in the state. It will not restrict law enforcement agencies from using databanks maintained by private companies like 23andMe or Ancestry, which are used for genetic genealogy research.

While the State Legislature authorized the creation of the state’s DNA databank in 1994, it only allowed for the collection and searching of samples from people convicted of crimes, not relatives of those individuals.

According to New York’s Division of Criminal Justice Services, the state has approved just 30 applications from law enforcement to conduct familial DNA searches, which has led to matches in 10 cases, with two resulting in arrests.

Spokesman for the DCJS Janine Kava said the agency was reviewing the decision and may bring the case to the Court of Appeals.

Supervising attorney for the Legal Aid Society’s DNA Unit Jenny S. Cheung argued that the executive agencies of the DCJS and the forensic science commission, which voted to allow familial DNA searching in murder and rape cases without first obtaining state authorization, “acted well outside their purview and authority by unilaterally promulgating this far-reaching policy, one that should have been left to the legislature to debate.”

Categories: Policy Tags: New York, privacy, court, cold case, legislature, DNA database, familial DNA searching, executive branch, Division of Criminal Justice Services, racial discrimination

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • True detectives: Psychological realities of investigative work
  • Crime problems are community problems
  • Putting the brakes on wandering cops
  • Effective use of chaplain services
  • Tucson tries new tact to fight crime
  • An equation for performing lawful Terry stops
  • Things I learned as a retiree
  • Memorializing our fallen sisters
  • Normalization of deviance
  • 2022 Top Cops

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

The power of teamwork

The power of teamwork

July 23, 2021

Stay awake and alert on the job

Stay awake and alert on the job

July 20, 2021

The worst rank in law enforcement

The worst rank in law enforcement

July 19, 2021

Firearms maintenance

Firearms maintenance

July 04, 2021

Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2022 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close
Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.