• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Subscribe to the Magazine
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Editor’s Picks
    • The power of teamwork
      Stay awake and alert on the job
      The worst rank in law enforcement
      Firearms maintenance
      Why fries need salt
  • Topics
    • On the Job
      • Boulder police recover $400,000 in stolen paintings, drug stash in...
        California police officer rescues three people from car teetering on...
        Stranded driver gets gas refill from helpful police officer
        “I felt like it was my job”: North Carolina officer honored for...
        Ohio police officer goes the extra mile to feed and clothe homeless...
    • Labor
      • Florida pays out $5M in hiring bonuses for more than one thousand...
        Cops leave NYPD in highest number since 9/11
        California police department to pay academy costs to boost recruiting...
        Indiana police department offering $10,000 signing bonus to lateral...
        “The game has clearly changed”: Police departments employ variety...
    • Tech
      • Minnesota law enforcement agencies turn to facial recognition...
        Vehicle infotainment systems vulnerable to hacking
        “It is a game changer:” Minnesota county implements mobile...
        Ohio police lay a trap to nab porch pirates
        Oceanside Police Department unveils new crime-mapping tool to protect...
    • Training
      • Pennsylvania police utilize VR for de-escalation training
        Running your patrol rifle like a champion
        Present ability, opportunity and apparent intent
        Defensive tactics
        Mechanics, consistency and aggression
    • Policy
      • Arkansas sheriff’s offices refuse to enforce federal ATF gun policy
        President Biden signs bill expanding national missing persons database
        California Highway Patrol spotlights new traffic laws for 2023
        Texas law enforcement leaders say the state has too many police...
        Justice Department launches new language initiative after resolving...
    • Health/Wellness
      • Coping with internal investigation or legal action
        The value of data: Wellness through the eyes of officers
        What officers love, hope and worry about
        Don’t be “that guy” — get moving
        Compassion fatigue
    • Community
      • LAPD chief bans “Thin Blue Line” flag from department use
        Friday Night Lights duty
        Oklahoma law enforcement teach children self-defense tactics to build...
        Former Superman actor thanks police officers for their...
        Colorado police department establishes safety zones for internet...
    • Offbeat
      • Drunk-driving suspect performs backflip for Ohio police during...
        “Like a scene from ‘Home Alone’”: Georgia man slips on ice...
        “Some real sitcom stuff there”: Florida burglars call 9-1-1 for...
        Wyoming police officer restores classic Chevy Bel Air as police...
        Santa Cruz police arrest 19-year-old for handing out fake parking...
    • We Remember
      • “I had a calling”: Colorado cadet inspired by fallen hero Eric...
        Chicago police remember fallen and injured officers this holiday...
        Deputy killed by roommate after he “jokingly” pulled trigger of...
        Maryland’s oldest cold case solved
        At least 13 officers shot in five days as wave of violence sweeps...
  • On the Job
    • Boulder police recover $400,000 in stolen paintings, drug stash in...
      California police officer rescues three people from car teetering on...
      Stranded driver gets gas refill from helpful police officer
      “I felt like it was my job”: North Carolina officer honored for...
      Ohio police officer goes the extra mile to feed and clothe homeless...
  • Labor
    • Florida pays out $5M in hiring bonuses for more than one thousand...
      Cops leave NYPD in highest number since 9/11
      California police department to pay academy costs to boost recruiting...
      Indiana police department offering $10,000 signing bonus to lateral...
      “The game has clearly changed”: Police departments employ variety...
  • Tech
    • Minnesota law enforcement agencies turn to facial recognition...
      Vehicle infotainment systems vulnerable to hacking
      “It is a game changer:” Minnesota county implements mobile...
      Ohio police lay a trap to nab porch pirates
      Oceanside Police Department unveils new crime-mapping tool to protect...
  • Training
    • Pennsylvania police utilize VR for de-escalation training
      Running your patrol rifle like a champion
      Present ability, opportunity and apparent intent
      Defensive tactics
      Mechanics, consistency and aggression
  • Policy
    • Arkansas sheriff’s offices refuse to enforce federal ATF gun policy
      President Biden signs bill expanding national missing persons database
      California Highway Patrol spotlights new traffic laws for 2023
      Texas law enforcement leaders say the state has too many police...
      Justice Department launches new language initiative after resolving...
  • Health/Wellness
    • Coping with internal investigation or legal action
      The value of data: Wellness through the eyes of officers
      What officers love, hope and worry about
      Don’t be “that guy” — get moving
      Compassion fatigue
  • Community
    • LAPD chief bans “Thin Blue Line” flag from department use
      Friday Night Lights duty
      Oklahoma law enforcement teach children self-defense tactics to build...
      Former Superman actor thanks police officers for their...
      Colorado police department establishes safety zones for internet...
  • Offbeat
    • Drunk-driving suspect performs backflip for Ohio police during...
      “Like a scene from ‘Home Alone’”: Georgia man slips on ice...
      “Some real sitcom stuff there”: Florida burglars call 9-1-1 for...
      Wyoming police officer restores classic Chevy Bel Air as police...
      Santa Cruz police arrest 19-year-old for handing out fake parking...
  • We Remember
    • “I had a calling”: Colorado cadet inspired by fallen hero Eric...
      Chicago police remember fallen and injured officers this holiday...
      Deputy killed by roommate after he “jokingly” pulled trigger of...
      Maryland’s oldest cold case solved
      At least 13 officers shot in five days as wave of violence sweeps...
  • Between the Lines
    • Persecution of the LEO is Classic Schadenfreude
      The Rule of Law is Worthless Without Order
      School policing: a paradox of the defund movement
      Defending the honor of the LE profession – finally!
      The dichotomy of the defund movement: reality setting in
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Search

Policy

Supreme Court vacates ruling saying officers used reasonable force in restraining a prisoner before he died

APB Team Published July 8, 2021 @ 4:00 pm PDT

iStock.com/arsenisspyros

Days after former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin was sentenced for the murder of George Floyd, SCOTUS vacated a ruling in a similar case in Lombardo v. City of St. Louis that held that officers used reasonable force when using similar restraints against a prisoner that ultimately led to his demise.

The Supreme Court ruled to vacate the decision made by the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, claiming they failed to fully examine the situation. Now, they are sending the case of Nicholas Gilbert back to the lower courts.

Nicholas Gilbert’s parents sued the City of St. Louis after their son died while being restrained by multiple officers in a St. Louis prison. According to a Fox News report, officers pinned Gilbert face down with pressure on his back and torso for 15 minutes after officers believed he was attempting to hang himself. 

“We express no view as to whether the officers used unconstitutionally excessive force or, if they did, whether Gilbert’s right to be free of such force in these circumstances was clearly established at the time of his death,” the court said. “We instead grant the petition for certiorari, vacate the judgment of the Eighth Circuit, and remand the case to give the court the opportunity to employ an inquiry that clearly attends to the facts and circumstances in answering those questions in the first instance.”

The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals had apparently cited a case in their decision that ruled that prone restraint was not “objectively unreasonable” if the detainee was resisting. 

Gilbert apparently struggled against officers and kicked at them when they tried to handcuff him. Six officers entered the cell to eventually subdue Gilbert, and apparently pinned him after handcuffing him and putting him in leg restraints.

Gilbert said, “‘It hurts. Stop,” his parents claimed, and after 15 minutes he stopped moving. The officers performed CPR after failing to detect a pulse, and then an ambulance took him to a hospital where he was pronounced dead.

In the 6-3 ruling to vacate, the Supreme Court ruled that the Eighth Circuit’s error was that while they relied on a precedent while ignoring facts such as the duration of the hold, and the use of cuffs and shackles before the hold was applied. The court also ignored instructions given to St. Louis officers that warned that pressure on a prone person’s back could cause suffocation. 

The Supreme Court also pointed to police guidelines that said subjects on their stomachs should be lifted after being handcuffed to prevent suffocation, and that if a subject continues to struggle, it could be a physical reaction to oxygen depletion and not an attempt to resist officers.

Justice Samuel Alito, Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch dissented.

Alito wrote that the lower court made a decision with a fair legal standard and that the Supreme Court should either have let the ruling stand or decide the real issue.

We have two respectable options: deny review of the factbound question that the case presents or grant the petition, have the case briefed and argued, roll up our sleeves, and decide the real issue,” Alito wrote. “I favor the latter course, but what we should not do is take the easy out that the Court has chosen.”

Categories: Policy Tags: Police, Law Enforcement, Supreme court, SCOTUS, reasonable force, Lombardo, St. Louis

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • Minnesota law enforcement agencies turn to facial recognition technology to identify potential suspects
  • LAPD chief bans “Thin Blue Line” flag from department use
  • Boulder police recover $400,000 in stolen paintings, drug stash in hotel room
  • Pennsylvania police utilize VR for de-escalation training
  • California police officer rescues three people from car teetering on cliff edge
  • Florida pays out $5M in hiring bonuses for more than one thousand officers over past six months
  • Cops leave NYPD in highest number since 9/11
  • California police department to pay academy costs to boost recruiting and offset labor shortages
  • Vehicle infotainment systems vulnerable to hacking
  • Drunk-driving suspect performs backflip for Ohio police during sobriety test

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

The power of teamwork

The power of teamwork

July 23, 2021

Stay awake and alert on the job

Stay awake and alert on the job

July 20, 2021

The worst rank in law enforcement

The worst rank in law enforcement

July 19, 2021

Firearms maintenance

Firearms maintenance

July 04, 2021

Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2023 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close
Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.