• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Subscribe
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Leadership
    • Setting ethical expectations early in an officer’s career
      Go that extra mile with a smile
      Improving the promotional process for supervisors
      Developing an ethics-centered police department
      Leadership without the family factor is not leadership
  • Topics
    • Leadership
      • Setting ethical expectations early in an officer’s career
        Go that extra mile with a smile
        Improving the promotional process for supervisors
        Developing an ethics-centered police department
        Leadership without the family factor is not leadership
    • Editor’s Picks
      • Off duty, but never off guard
        The tyranny of memories
        Meeting training needs on a limited budget
        Empowering through experience
        Getting ahead of the story
    • On the Job
      • Reckless elegance
        No case too cold
        Summer is coming
        Securing the Texas border one K-9 team at a time
        Empowering through experience
    • Labor
      • Critical incidents and waiting woosah
        Insufficient police staffing continues throughout the U.S.
        The righteous battle
        Recruitment and retention
        Austin police chief aims to end officer shortage as recruitment...
    • Tech
      • Your website is your front desk
        Telegram investigations
        Florida sheriff’s office deploys cutting-edge forensic tool to...
        A new chapter for Utah law enforcement
        Is AI the future of report writing?
    • Training
      • Training vs. practice: Improve or maintain?
        Off duty, but never off guard
        Meeting training needs on a limited budget
        Be a thermostat, not a thermometer
        Duty knives: Practical or just “tacticool”
    • Policy
      • Michigan Supreme Court: Marijuana odor alone no longer justifies...
        Milwaukee P.D. and schools clash over SROs
        Seattle Police Department launches new plan to curb violent crime
        Buffer-zone law blocked in Louisiana
        Dakota’s Law: Pensions for police dogs?
    • Health/Wellness
      • Keeping work at work and home at home
        Avoiding the road to burnout
        Texas sheriff’s office hit with series of suicides
        The tyranny of memories
        “Why are you mad at me?”
    • Community
      • San Diego Honors Fallen Officer Austin Machitar with Park Renaming
        Battle of the Badges baseball game to support injured Missouri officer
        Temple University Police celebrate 7-year-old’s support with...
        A local problem with a statewide solution
        From traffic stops to tip-offs: Iowa officer becomes basketball...
    • Offbeat
      • Not eggzactly a perfect heist
        Pizza … with a side of alligator?
        Wisconsin man charged with impersonating Border Patrol agent twice in...
        Only in California?
        Durango, Colorado, police hop into action after unusual 9-1-1 call
    • We Remember
      • Honoring Fallen Heroes
        What’s with the white chairs?
        The pain and sorrow of loss
        A cop and his car
        A dream of remembrance
    • HOT Mail
      • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • On the Job
    • Reckless elegance
      No case too cold
      Summer is coming
      Securing the Texas border one K-9 team at a time
      Empowering through experience
  • Labor
    • Critical incidents and waiting woosah
      Insufficient police staffing continues throughout the U.S.
      The righteous battle
      Recruitment and retention
      Austin police chief aims to end officer shortage as recruitment...
  • Tech
    • Your website is your front desk
      Telegram investigations
      Florida sheriff’s office deploys cutting-edge forensic tool to...
      A new chapter for Utah law enforcement
      Is AI the future of report writing?
  • Training
    • Training vs. practice: Improve or maintain?
      Off duty, but never off guard
      Meeting training needs on a limited budget
      Be a thermostat, not a thermometer
      Duty knives: Practical or just “tacticool”
  • Policy
    • Michigan Supreme Court: Marijuana odor alone no longer justifies...
      Milwaukee P.D. and schools clash over SROs
      Seattle Police Department launches new plan to curb violent crime
      Buffer-zone law blocked in Louisiana
      Dakota’s Law: Pensions for police dogs?
  • Health/Wellness
    • Keeping work at work and home at home
      Avoiding the road to burnout
      Texas sheriff’s office hit with series of suicides
      The tyranny of memories
      “Why are you mad at me?”
  • Community
    • San Diego Honors Fallen Officer Austin Machitar with Park Renaming
      Battle of the Badges baseball game to support injured Missouri officer
      Temple University Police celebrate 7-year-old’s support with...
      A local problem with a statewide solution
      From traffic stops to tip-offs: Iowa officer becomes basketball...
  • Offbeat
    • Not eggzactly a perfect heist
      Pizza … with a side of alligator?
      Wisconsin man charged with impersonating Border Patrol agent twice in...
      Only in California?
      Durango, Colorado, police hop into action after unusual 9-1-1 call
  • We Remember
    • Honoring Fallen Heroes
      What’s with the white chairs?
      The pain and sorrow of loss
      A cop and his car
      A dream of remembrance
  • HOT Mail
    • The War on Cops Continues Unabated
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
Search

Policy

U.S. Supreme Court sidesteps ruling on ‘qualified immunity’ in NJ police shooting case

APB Team Published October 10, 2021 @ 3:00 pm PDT

iStock.com/arsenisspyros

The U.S. Supreme Court recently rejected an appeal over a New Jersey police shooting case involving the controversial legal defense of “qualified immunity” that protects officers from civil litigation, an issue the court has already avoided weighing in on earlier this year.

According to a Reuters report, the court rejected an appeal by the mother of the shooting victim of a lower court’s decision that upheld the officer’s “qualified immunity” – a doctrine that grants police officers defense against civil lawsuits for actions carried out on duty.

Liberal judge Sonia Sotomayor dissented from the decision, thereby denying the case. However, in her dissent, she said that qualified immunity “does not protect an officer who inflicts deadly force on a person who is only a threat to himself.”

The lawsuit regarded the 2011 shooting of Willie Gibbons, a schizophrenic man, by a State Trooper Noah Bartlet after Gibbons pointed a gun at his own head and refused to drop the weapon. Bartlet shot Gibbons twice in the chest before his gun jammed.

The original ruling by the Philadelphia-based 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favor of Bartlet, concluding that although Gibbons was pointing the gun on himself, he was in range to potentially shoot the officer.

Gibbons’ family then filed a civil rights lawsuit against Bartelt and state police seeking monetary damages. While one federal judge handling the lawsuit denied Bartelt qualified immunity, a three-judge panel of the 3rd Circuit then reversed that ruling.

The doctrine of qualified immunity has been a point of controversy since the death of George Floyd this year, with some states such as New York eliminating the practice completely. Critics says it shields officers from accountability for misconduct, while law enforcement professionals argue it is essential for police to make quick decisions in the moment without fear of legal reprisal.

Qualified immunity is applicable in civil lawsuits unless it is “clearly established” that a victims’ statutory or constitutional rights have been violated.

The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the case is the second instance this year that they have dodged making a ruling.

In March, the court rejected a lawsuit against police for a 2016 incident in which the defendant, Shase Howse, claimed excessive force was used against him. The original ruling upheld the officers’ qualified immunity and said there was no evidence that constitutional rights were violated.

Categories: Policy Tags: George Floyd, qualified immunity case, legal defense, Willie Gibbons, accountability, Police Reform, Police, Supreme court, lawsuit, New Jersey

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • Training vs. practice: Improve or maintain?
  • Reckless elegance
  • Keeping work at work and home at home
  • Critical incidents and waiting woosah
  • Setting ethical expectations early in an officer’s career
  • Your website is your front desk
  • San Diego Honors Fallen Officer Austin Machitar with Park Renaming
  • Avoiding the road to burnout
  • National Police Week 2025
  • A look into National Police Week

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

Off duty, but never off guard

Off duty, but never off guard

May 05, 2025

The tyranny of memories

The tyranny of memories

May 04, 2025

Meeting training needs on a limited budget

Meeting training needs on a limited budget

May 02, 2025

Empowering through experience

Empowering through experience

April 18, 2025

Policies | Consent Preferences | Copyright © 2025 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close

Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.