• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Subscribe to the Magazine
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Editor’s Picks
    • The power of teamwork
      Stay awake and alert on the job
      The worst rank in law enforcement
      Firearms maintenance
      Why fries need salt
  • Topics
    • On the Job
      • “Take care of your veterans”: Massachusetts police save suicidal...
        The problems with loyalty
        My experience being a Black woman in policing
        Tucson tries new tact to fight crime
        2022 Top Cops
    • Labor
      • Philadelphia may rehire officers and civilian employees to fill...
        Chicago police recruit Marines to help address officer shortage
        Illinois State Police announce lateral training program with added...
        The “great resignation” brings staffing troubles to Missouri law...
        NYPD overtime expected to surpass budget by over $142 million to...
    • Tech
      • NYPD deploys K-9s with innovative electronic harness to prevent...
        Understanding end-to-end encryption apps
        Local law enforcement agencies learn to recover stolen cryptocurrency
        New York mayor proposes gun detection scanners after rise in subway...
        Hacker group steals data from multiple law enforcement data systems...
    • Training
      • An equation for performing lawful Terry stops
        A Connecticut police chief says his department needs more drug...
        “The hidden danger is the water”
        Weapon retention
        Developing trauma-informed training and drills for K–12 schools
    • Policy
      • Philadelphia spends almost a billion dollars on policing in new...
        Supreme Court decision protects police officers against civil...
        Chicago police limit foot pursuits under new policy intended to...
        Putting the brakes on wandering cops
        Detroit police team up with federal law enforcement agencies to fight...
    • Health/Wellness
      • True detectives: Psychological realities of investigative work
        Effective use of chaplain services
        Things I learned as a retiree
        Normalization of deviance
        The nobility of policing
    • Community
      • Miami Heat and nonprofit build bridges between law enforcement and...
        Right place, right time: Off-duty Florida police officer braves house...
        Community steps up to support Rhode Island police officer brothers...
        Safety exchange zones
        Crime problems are community problems
    • Offbeat
      • Iowa police and fire agencies, community team up to rescue bulldog...
        Buzz fuzz: NYPD “bee unit” officers remove swarms from various...
        Only in Florida: Police snipers provide backup during...
        Longtime Maryland con man arrested for impersonating U.S. marshal
        Seattle cancels and refunds seven months of parking tickets due to...
    • We Remember
      • Memorializing our fallen sisters
        Paying Tribute to Fallen Heroes
        National Law Enforcement Memorial expands to accommodate more names
        National Police Week
        “It’s not enough to never forget anymore”
  • On the Job
    • “Take care of your veterans”: Massachusetts police save suicidal...
      The problems with loyalty
      My experience being a Black woman in policing
      Tucson tries new tact to fight crime
      2022 Top Cops
  • Labor
    • Philadelphia may rehire officers and civilian employees to fill...
      Chicago police recruit Marines to help address officer shortage
      Illinois State Police announce lateral training program with added...
      The “great resignation” brings staffing troubles to Missouri law...
      NYPD overtime expected to surpass budget by over $142 million to...
  • Tech
    • NYPD deploys K-9s with innovative electronic harness to prevent...
      Understanding end-to-end encryption apps
      Local law enforcement agencies learn to recover stolen cryptocurrency
      New York mayor proposes gun detection scanners after rise in subway...
      Hacker group steals data from multiple law enforcement data systems...
  • Training
    • An equation for performing lawful Terry stops
      A Connecticut police chief says his department needs more drug...
      “The hidden danger is the water”
      Weapon retention
      Developing trauma-informed training and drills for K–12 schools
  • Policy
    • Philadelphia spends almost a billion dollars on policing in new...
      Supreme Court decision protects police officers against civil...
      Chicago police limit foot pursuits under new policy intended to...
      Putting the brakes on wandering cops
      Detroit police team up with federal law enforcement agencies to fight...
  • Health/Wellness
    • True detectives: Psychological realities of investigative work
      Effective use of chaplain services
      Things I learned as a retiree
      Normalization of deviance
      The nobility of policing
  • Community
    • Miami Heat and nonprofit build bridges between law enforcement and...
      Right place, right time: Off-duty Florida police officer braves house...
      Community steps up to support Rhode Island police officer brothers...
      Safety exchange zones
      Crime problems are community problems
  • Offbeat
    • Iowa police and fire agencies, community team up to rescue bulldog...
      Buzz fuzz: NYPD “bee unit” officers remove swarms from various...
      Only in Florida: Police snipers provide backup during...
      Longtime Maryland con man arrested for impersonating U.S. marshal
      Seattle cancels and refunds seven months of parking tickets due to...
  • We Remember
    • Memorializing our fallen sisters
      Paying Tribute to Fallen Heroes
      National Law Enforcement Memorial expands to accommodate more names
      National Police Week
      “It’s not enough to never forget anymore”
  • Between the Lines
    • Persecution of the LEO is Classic Schadenfreude
      The Rule of Law is Worthless Without Order
      School policing: a paradox of the defund movement
      Defending the honor of the LE profession – finally!
      The dichotomy of the defund movement: reality setting in
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Search

Training

Firearms vs. scenario-based training

Todd Fletcher Published March 16, 2021 @ 5:00 pm PDT

A properly designed scenario is a safe and effective way to test skills such as tactics, threat assessment and use-of-force decision-making. (Team One Network)

There has been a disturbing trend in law enforcement firearms training: Many departments are spending more time and resources on scenario-based training and less time on the range. Whether you call it scenario-based or reality-based, this type of training has merit and a place in our training programs. However, it is not firearms training and should not be considered a replacement for live-fire drills.

Before I get too deep in the weeds here, don’t believe for a minute that I’m not a fan of reality-based scenario training; I’m a huge proponent. As a matter of fact, while running the training division of my agency, I made it mandatory on a quarterly basis, so don’t get all bent out of shape thinking I’m down on this type of training. However, a guy who later took over that position reduced live-fire range training to the point where a newly hired officer was “qualified” using marking rounds in the police department garage instead of going to the range. Idiotic? You bet. But don’t believe for a second that it couldn’t happen at your department, too.

Reality-based scenarios are primarily decision-making exercises to assess threats, determine appropriate tactics and apply a reasonable amount of force. This is important stuff. However, skill development is done on the live-fire range, where quality training allows officers to work on their firearms skills. Firearms training puts officers in a structured training environment where they can perform multiple repetitions to improve a skill. Drawing from the holster, reloading, working through malfunctions, target transitions, multiple shots, changing speeds and other skills are best built on the live-fire range. Reality-based scenarios can supplement live-fire range training, but they cannot replace it.

Reality-based training

Combative Firearms Training, LLC

Scenario-based training without instruction and repetition is a test of skills. Just like qualification, reality-based training is a test where the instructors run the scenario but do not focus on teaching or coaching. If instructors aren’t teaching before and during the scenario, it is not training. The only time allotted to “train” in these dynamic scenarios is the debriefing following the exercise. By then, the training opportunity has mostly disappeared. Telling someone what they did wrong may be enlightening, but it is not training. And while those who respond well to verbal instruction may glean helpful information from the debriefing, most officers won’t learn much.

Taking this a step further, if instructors are not providing training, they should be considered proctors or evaluators. There is a time and place for this type of testing, but don’t fool yourself into thinking officers are receiving significant training value.

The use of reality-based scenarios should be viewed as a test of skills or a final exam. It is an opportunity to demonstrate a variety of skills, under stress, within compressed time frames, in a safe and controlled environment. A well-designed scenario can incorporate more than just the use of firearms in a shoot/no-shoot situation. It can include less-lethal options, officer down drills, buddy and self-rescue, team movement, triage, realistic radio traffic to dispatch and responding officers … the list goes on and on. But without repetition and timely instruction, this is not training. Each of the skills to be incorporated in a scenario should be trained in detail before being performed in a quasi-realistic situation. We would never ask our officers to perform a simulated swift water rescue without providing training on the skills needed to make the rescue attempt. So, why are we so willing to give up time spent on the range, mastering the fundamentals of marksmanship and weapon handling?

Live-fire range training

Most scenarios can’t be repeated, but this is a perfect place to test de-escalation and officer safety skills. (Antonio “Instructor Z” Zarzoza)

It is impractical to demonstrate and repeat reality-based scenarios. This is why well-designed drills on the range are so important. Range drills allow instructors to observe each shooter’s performance, and the repetition provides an opportunity for the instructor to provide coaching to help the shooter master that skill.

Repetition gives students the ability to learn skills. Skills must be taught, understood, learned, practiced and mastered to the point of “unconscious competence.” This is what many consider “autopilot.” It’s actually called automaticity, which is defined as the ability to do something without occupying the mind with low-level details. When officers are in a fight to save their lives or the lives of others, they shouldn’t think about how individual skills are performed. They need to focus on the fight and what is required to prevail. Physical shooting skills must be performed without conscious thought.

The live-fire range is the place to focus on the officer’s ability to put rounds on target consistently, within restricted time constraints. The training environment is the safest place to fail. By allowing officers to fail in a controlled environment with the opportunity to repeat a drill until they become proficient, instructors are providing training. The pressure of the test is off, and skill acquisition is the goal. If we do not push ourselves to the point of failure, we never know our true abilities. By pushing our limits past our current abilities, we provide an opportunity for improvement.

When officers are proficient in the skills to be tested, then scenarios should be used to test those skills. If officers are not equipped with the skills they need, they are being set up for failure. The debriefing will tell them what they did right and what they did wrong, but without repetition, there is no way to measure the effectiveness of training or the improvement of skills.

Live-fire range training provides an opportunity for officers to work through multiple repetitions of different skills under the watchful eye of an instructor. (Combative Firearms Training, LLC)

Why is this happening?

There could be several causes for the current trend of replacing range time with scenarios. Many trainers do not understand the learning process and don’t know what they don’t know. They are falling victim to their training deficiencies, and the cycle continues. They may be excited to use all the “cool gadgets” involved in reality-based training but lack the understanding of how to properly utilize these tools.

In addition, the people in charge of budgeting, scheduling and designing training programs may not understand how they are failing their officers by making the switch from firearms training to scenarios. Many view it as killing two birds with one stone, and when they are being asked to do more with less, they see this as a good compromise. But it is not a compromise; it is a tradeoff. Incorporating scenarios will add diversity and strengthen a training program, but it should never replace time spent training skills imperative to surviving the job. Besides, not every scenario should end with a force response.

We need to push our training programs to be progressive and stay relevant. While attempting to do this, too many departments are falling prey to trendy training without evaluating their program using a critical eye. While reality-based training and the use of scenarios has a lot to offer, it is testing. It should never replace valuable time spent on the range, teaching and coaching officers on the fundamentals of marksmanship and how to place rounds on target under time duress.

Todd Fletcher

Todd Fletcher

Todd Fletcher is a retired sergeant from central Oregon with over 25 years of law enforcement experience. He presents firearms training and instructor development classes nationwide. Todd has presented at multiple regional, national and international conferences, including multiple ILEETA conferences and IALEFI events. He is also a charter member and staff instructor for NLEFIA. He owns Combative Firearms Training, LLC, providing firearms training and instructor development classes to law enforcement, military, private security and armed citizens. He can be contacted at Todd@CombativeFirearms.com.

View articles by Todd Fletcher

As seen in the March 2021 issue of American Police Beat magazine.
Don’t miss out on another issue today! Click below:

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

Categories: Training

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • Philadelphia spends almost a billion dollars on policing in new budget aimed at addressing gun violence
  • Miami Heat and nonprofit build bridges between law enforcement and community
  • Right place, right time: Off-duty Florida police officer braves house fire to rescue trapped children
  • “Take care of your veterans”: Massachusetts police save suicidal veteran
  • Iowa police and fire agencies, community team up to rescue bulldog stuck in sinkhole
  • Community steps up to support Rhode Island police officer brothers who lost everything in a house fire
  • Supreme Court decision protects police officers against civil lawsuits over Miranda rights violations
  • NYPD deploys K-9s with innovative electronic harness to prevent terrorist attacks
  • The problems with loyalty
  • Chicago police limit foot pursuits under new policy intended to enhance officer safety and public trust

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

The power of teamwork

The power of teamwork

July 23, 2021

Stay awake and alert on the job

Stay awake and alert on the job

July 20, 2021

The worst rank in law enforcement

The worst rank in law enforcement

July 19, 2021

Firearms maintenance

Firearms maintenance

July 04, 2021

Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2022 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close
Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.