• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Subscribe to the Magazine
American Police Beat

American Police Beat Magazine

Law Enforcement Publication

  • Home
  • Editor’s Picks
    • Seeking the right kind of help
      “Why does that call keep haunting me?”
      Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em
      A message to those considering suicide
      The power of teamwork
  • Topics
    • On the Job
      • “Wow, our career together is over”: Missouri police department...
        Heroic Pennsylvania officer saves father and daughter from drowning...
        Denver law enforcement struggle to divert low-level offenders to...
        “The good guys won”: Fugitive convicted murderer captured after...
        “Service was running through his veins”: Condolences pour in for...
    • Labor
      • San Francisco “workhorse” deputy earns millions in overtime pay...
        “A financial tsunami”
        LAPD officers receive raises, bonuses
        Minnesota police force faces disbandment as chief resigns amid salary...
        We quit!
    • Tech
      • The rise of I2P
        Ann Arbor Police Department adopts AI technology to analyze body...
        Ohio law enforcement adopts powerful ballistics technology to combat...
        AI-powered surveillance program raises concerns over privacy rights...
        Chesterfield County announces real-time crime center to enhance...
    • Training
      • Investigating “swatting” incidents
        Leaders take note: A handwritten note goes a long way
        CIT training is not for everyone
        Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em
        Ohio struggles to secure permanent funding for law enforcement...
    • Policy
      • Texas enacts stricter laws to combat illegal street racing and...
        New Mexico Supreme Court clarifies police authority to question...
        New Texas law gives local law enforcement greater control over...
        Diversity in law enforcement
        Florida attorney general and John Walsh partner in new Crime Stoppers...
    • Health/Wellness
      • The emotional rucksack
        What threat does to the brain
        Seeking the right kind of help
        Working through grief
        Responding to trauma
    • Community
      • Florida police department launches SPORTS initiative to build...
        Naperville police officer inspires generations of kids through reading
        Stockton P.D. launches Your Way Registry Program to protect...
        Committing to outreach
        Scam callers pose as law enforcement to trick victims into paying for...
    • Offbeat
      • “This little piggy didn’t make it to the market”:
        Seattle police find burglary suspect guzzling gasoline in victim’s...
        Univision Chicago TV crew reporting on armed robberies held at...
        California Highway Patrol arrests man on horseback for DUI
        Runaway lemur leads Missouri police on wild chase
    • We Remember
      • Headstone finally marks grave of Pennsylvania officer who gave his...
        Memorial for the fallen: The sacrifice continues
        Paying Tribute to the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
        “He was like a protector …”: Genesee County sheriff’s deputy...
        Deadly police pursuit claims life of 19-year-old Vermont police...
  • On the Job
    • “Wow, our career together is over”: Missouri police department...
      Heroic Pennsylvania officer saves father and daughter from drowning...
      Denver law enforcement struggle to divert low-level offenders to...
      “The good guys won”: Fugitive convicted murderer captured after...
      “Service was running through his veins”: Condolences pour in for...
  • Labor
    • San Francisco “workhorse” deputy earns millions in overtime pay...
      “A financial tsunami”
      LAPD officers receive raises, bonuses
      Minnesota police force faces disbandment as chief resigns amid salary...
      We quit!
  • Tech
    • The rise of I2P
      Ann Arbor Police Department adopts AI technology to analyze body...
      Ohio law enforcement adopts powerful ballistics technology to combat...
      AI-powered surveillance program raises concerns over privacy rights...
      Chesterfield County announces real-time crime center to enhance...
  • Training
    • Investigating “swatting” incidents
      Leaders take note: A handwritten note goes a long way
      CIT training is not for everyone
      Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em
      Ohio struggles to secure permanent funding for law enforcement...
  • Policy
    • Texas enacts stricter laws to combat illegal street racing and...
      New Mexico Supreme Court clarifies police authority to question...
      New Texas law gives local law enforcement greater control over...
      Diversity in law enforcement
      Florida attorney general and John Walsh partner in new Crime Stoppers...
  • Health/Wellness
    • The emotional rucksack
      What threat does to the brain
      Seeking the right kind of help
      Working through grief
      Responding to trauma
  • Community
    • Florida police department launches SPORTS initiative to build...
      Naperville police officer inspires generations of kids through reading
      Stockton P.D. launches Your Way Registry Program to protect...
      Committing to outreach
      Scam callers pose as law enforcement to trick victims into paying for...
  • Offbeat
    • “This little piggy didn’t make it to the market”:
      Seattle police find burglary suspect guzzling gasoline in victim’s...
      Univision Chicago TV crew reporting on armed robberies held at...
      California Highway Patrol arrests man on horseback for DUI
      Runaway lemur leads Missouri police on wild chase
  • We Remember
    • Headstone finally marks grave of Pennsylvania officer who gave his...
      Memorial for the fallen: The sacrifice continues
      Paying Tribute to the Fallen Heroes of 9/11
      “He was like a protector …”: Genesee County sheriff’s deputy...
      Deadly police pursuit claims life of 19-year-old Vermont police...
  • Between the Lines
    • Debunking the perpetual narrative of racial bias in policing
      The unspoken truth behind the recruitment and retention crisis
      The police reform goal: use of force without options
      The imprisonment of law enforcement technology
      Persecution of the LEO is classic schadenfreude
  • About
  • The Magazine
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Products
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Search

On the Job

Think of de-escalation as conflict resolution

Dr. Megan Price Published May 11, 2022 @ 6:00 am PDT

iStock.com/Marco Piunti

De-escalation can be a foggy term. On the one hand, it refers to gaining control over an enforcement situation that is threatening to become uncontrollable. On the other, it refers to gaining voluntary compliance from the person contributing to the potentially uncontrollable situation. These goals can seem contradictory in practice, but they are clearly meant to be achieved together. According to the Seattle Police Department’s de-escalation policy, de-escalation tactics “seek to minimize the likelihood of the need to use force during an incident and increase the likelihood of voluntary compliance.” Adding to the fog is that there is no accepted standard of practice, and how to de-escalate varies across the board. Some officers use tools like tasers and body wrap, and others use verbal judo. When we think of de-escalation as a matter of conflict resolution — resolving the conflict behavior that drives the growing intensity of an enforcement situation — it becomes easier to stay focused in escalating encounters and draw on nonviolent communication skills to maintain control and secure compliance.

To get at this, let’s take a minute to look at escalation. Escalation is commonly considered a progressive increase in intensity. When it comes to law enforcement encounters with the public, this increase in intensity refers to the amount of power and force an officer employs to gain control in the face of resistance. The use-of-force continuum clearly illustrates this. Given an increase in subject resistance, an officer is permitted to use an increased amount of force to reduce resistance. As resistance subsides, intensity decreases, and a situation de-escalates. The operating assumption here is that by increasing force, we can short-circuit resistance and reduce the need for further force, which in turn ultimately leads to compliance. This is where less-lethal tools like tasers and body wrap come into play. They lessen the intensity of an encounter by incapacitating the subject, thereby reducing the need for more force. 

However, the idea that de-escalation is primarily a matter of lessening the intensity of a police encounter obscures that key element of voluntary compliance. When we focus on controlling degrees of intensity, our goal becomes the end state of when the struggle stops — when the subject is subdued and the officer wins. That said, a subject’s waning resistance in the face of a more powerful force does not equal compliance. It equals compulsion. The difference is that properly understood compliance is an act of agreement that is given when one has say in a matter and makes their own decision. When someone is compelled, they have no choice. Adding a conflict lens to our consideration of how best to de-escalate an enforcement situation can advance the goal of reducing the need for force, obtaining voluntary compliance and strengthening trust, legitimacy and community connection.

Conflict resolution scholars have been thinking about escalation and de-escalation for decades. The field describes escalation as what happens when we move from a disagreement to a fight. It illustrates it, as law enforcement does, as an increase in intensity — as growing from light to heavy tactics, from persuasions to threats of violence, from the goal of achieving specific changes to winning. Each of these is characterized by heightened efforts that draw on power and force. What happens when we fight, though, is that we often lose sight of why we are fighting and focus all our energy toward coming out on top. 

The trouble, as Kurt Lewin, one of the fathers of conflict resolution, demonstrates, is that using force to induce behavior change — to stop subject resistance, for example — is inefficient and counterproductive. It often leads to excessive force and harm, not to the outcomes we desire. Even if behavior is changed, in that a subject stops resisting, that change is likely infused with resentment, animosity and mistrust, which can lead to negative encounters later. What works better is to mitigate the elements that are leading a person to decide to resist in the first place. 

What does this mean? It means two things. First, to get compliance in the face of resistance, forcing someone is a strategy useful only as a last resort. Second, to proactively take the wind out of escalation’s sails, we must resist the temptation to escalate in kind. We need to not let a person’s resistance get the better of us and instead recognize it as conflict.

To do this, we can take a page from Insight Policing to explain. Insight Policing is a conflict resolution skill set taught to officers that is grounded in conflict scholarship and explains conflict in terms of decision-making. Expressly, conflict behaviors — the things we do in conflict, like resisting an officer through aggression or noncompliance — are the consequence of a decision to defend in response to a feeling of threat. The key here is the threat. When we feel threatened, we feel as though we are going to lose something immensely important — from our well-being to our dignity. Our brains are wired to defend against those threats. We will continue to defend until we feel adequately secure. 

Take the example of a person resisting a police directive to exit their vehicle. When we look at that resistance as conflict behavior, we can see that it is a decision to defend in response to a feeling of threat. Using force to decrease the driver’s resistance will predictably lead to more struggle before de-escalation in intensity is possible. This is because the perceived threat motivating the driver’s resistance has not been addressed, and the force compelling them to comply becomes an additional layer of threat to defend against. 

Provided there are no immediate dangers to anyone’s safety, an officer can reduce resistance early and prevent the need to escalate as a control technique by figuring out what threat is leading the driver to resist. The officer does not do this by guessing or assuming but by getting curious. When the officer can ask targeted questions that engage dialogue to uncover the threat, the officer discovers critical information. They discover what the driver is defending against — whatever it is that is getting in the way of the driver getting out of the car. When the officer can get that information — what feels threatening to the driver and is leading them to resist — the officer can use that information to help mitigate the threat and move the interaction productively forward. This not only gives the driver a voice, which cultivates a sense of fairness and connection, but encourages cooperation. The officer is no longer contributing to the driver’s sense of threat, but is positioned to ease it. This, in turn, positions the officer to do the work required of the traffic stop with the voluntary compliance of the driver. 

De-escalating in this way capitalizes on what works in conflict resolution. When officers can think of aggressive, resistant and noncompliant behavior as conflict behavior and of de-escalation as conflict resolution, they can balance the objectives of control and compliance. They can interrupt an escalating encounter by working to reduce the need of the other party to resist — not by overpowering it, but by discovering its cause — the threat motivating it in the first place. This achieves both the lessening of intensity that de-escalation tactics strive for and sets the stage for voluntary compliance.

Dr. Megan Price

Dr. Megan Price

Dr. Megan Price is the director of the Center for Applied Insight Conflict Resolution in Washington, D.C., and is founder and trainer of Insight Policing: Conflict Resolution for Law Enforcement (insightpolicing.com), which teaches officers the foundations of conflict decision-making and targeted, curiosity-based communication skills for controlling escalation and problem-solving effectively. Dr. Price is adjunct professor in Conflict Analysis and Resolution at George Mason University and associate faculty in the Conflict Management master’s program at Royal Roads University.

View articles by Dr. Megan Price

As seen in the May 2022 issue of American Police Beat magazine.
Don’t miss out on another issue today! Click below:

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

Categories: On the Job

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

  • “This little piggy didn’t make it to the market”:
  • Florida police department launches SPORTS initiative to build positive community relationships
  • Seattle police find burglary suspect guzzling gasoline in victim’s garage
  • The emotional rucksack
  • Naperville police officer inspires generations of kids through reading
  • “Wow, our career together is over”: Missouri police department bids farewell to retiring K-9 Tank
  • Investigating “swatting” incidents
  • Univision Chicago TV crew reporting on armed robberies held at gunpoint
  • Stockton P.D. launches Your Way Registry Program to protect individuals with mental and neurological disorders
  • What threat does to the brain

Footer

Our Mission
To serve as a trusted voice of the nation’s law enforcement community, providing informative, entertaining and inspiring content on interesting and engaging topics affecting peace officers today.

Contact us: info@apbweb.com | (800) 234-0056.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Categories

  • Editor’s Picks
  • On the Job
  • Labor
  • Tech
  • Training
  • Policy
  • Health/Wellness
  • Community
  • Offbeat
  • We Remember
  • Jobs and Careers
  • Events

Editor’s Picks

Seeking the right kind of help

Seeking the right kind of help

September 26, 2023

“Why does that call keep haunting me?”

“Why does that call keep haunting me?”

September 20, 2023

Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em

Mentoring: Leave ’em better than you found ’em

September 19, 2023

A message to those considering suicide

A message to those considering suicide

September 18, 2023

Privacy Policy | Your Privacy Options | Notice at Collection | Copyright © 2023 APB Media, LLC | Website design, development and maintenance by 911MEDIA

Open

Subscribe

Close

Receive the latest news and updates from American Police Beat directly to your inbox!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.